Sharing Israel? Divide between religious and secular Jews heats up under Netanyahu's rule
But with ultra-Orthodox parties now wielding unprecedented power in Israels new government and playing a key role in a contentious plan to overhaul the legal system they are aggravating concerns among secular Israelis that the character and future of their country is under threat.Thanks to its supercharged political clout, the haredi community has gained massive budgets that critics say will entrench its isolated way of life and weaken Israels economic prospects as the ultra-Orthodox population balloons.We have two kids.
The sound of children and music echoed down a narrow basement hallway in Israel as they scrambled in a pool of balls, climbed on a jungle gym, munched popcorn and laughed.
The atmosphere changed suddenly on that Saturday last month, as at least a dozen religious men appeared and blocked the entrance, accusing the indoor playground of desecrating the Jewish sabbath by opening for business. Angry parents confronted them, scuffles broke out and in an instant, the centre in this mixed city had become a flashpoint symbol of a larger battle between secular and religious Jews in Israel.
“I think it represents what's going on in the country,” said Tzipi Brayer Sharabi, a 38-year-old mother who says she was attacked and thrown to the ground during the May 20 incident. “I want my kids to live how they choose to live. I don't want somebody to tell them how they should eat, how they should dress, what they should do on Shabbat.'' Similar incidents have long upset the tenuous balance between the communities. But with ultra-Orthodox parties now wielding unprecedented power in Israel's new government — and playing a key role in a contentious plan to overhaul the legal system — they are aggravating concerns among secular Israelis that the character and future of their country is under threat.
Thanks to its supercharged political clout, the haredi community has gained massive budgets that critics say will entrench its isolated way of life and weaken Israel's economic prospects as the ultra-Orthodox population balloons.
“We have two kids. They have 10 kids. They're going to be the majority here, eventually,” said Brayer Sharabi, a secular Israeli whose elbow was broken in the scuffle. “What's going to happen to this place once they have the majority?” Israel's ultra-Orthodox, known as haredim, make up 13 per cent of the country's 9.7 million population. The cloistered community has long been at odds with the secular majority, clashing over military conscription, their integration into the workforce and the basic tenets that guide their lives. Haredi Jews in Israel also are growing faster than any other group, at about 4 per cent annually.
The many differences between religious and secular Jews have chafed the country throughout its 75 years. Under Netanyahu's government, the sense has sharpened among secular Israelis that their lifestyle may have an expiration date.
Netanyahu, meanwhile, brushes off such criticism, saying the ultra-Orthodox are Israeli citizens who deserve funding and that he is working to integrate them into the workforce.
The ultra-Orthodox mostly live in separate towns and city neighbourhoods, and unlike most secular Jews, most are not conscripted in the military under a decades-old system of exemptions that allows them to study religious texts instead. Many continue religious study well into adulthood and do not work, living off government stipends and grating on the nerves of the country's tax-paying middle class.
Ultra-Orthodox schools widely do not teach a core curriculum of math or English. Experts say this gives them few skills to enter the work world, creating a recipe for poverty and increased dependence on government assistance as the population grows.
The ultra-Orthodox say their children nonetheless deserve robust state funding for education, and that their otherwise insular communities protect a centuries-old way of life. Their leaders also say they contribute to the economy by paying significant sums of sales tax on consumer purchases for their large families.
Yinon Azulai, a lawmaker with the ultra-Orthodox Shas party, last month in a parliament speech denounced what he called “the wild incitement raging these days and running in the streets of baseless hatred for the ultra-Orthodox community” after a popular TV host called the community “blood suckers.” “I don't intend to apologise for being haredi,” he said on the Knesset floor.
Gilad Malach, director of the ultra-Orthodox in Israel Programme at the Israel Democracy Institute, a think tank, said that the large budget was part of a broader trend showing the community is not integrating with the country's larger society.
“The last few years we have more and more signs that this process is not strong enough,” he said. “People ask themselves, what is the direction that (the) Israeli state goes?” Dan Ben-David, an economist who has long criticised what he says is preferential treatment for the ultra-Orthodox, said the generous subsidies and political power provide a glimpse of Israel's future.
“Not a day goes by where we're not inundated with a clear picture of what's life going to be like” under an ultra-Orthodox majority, said Ben-David, president of Tel Aviv University's Shoresh Institution for Socioeconomic Research. “The level of tension is much higher.” The tens of millions of dollars in financial handouts passed in the recent budget last month have enraged secular Israelis.
Weekly protests against the legal overhaul have sometimes adopted anti-religious themes, especially ahead of a court-ordered July 31 deadline for Netanyahu to submit a new law to address the issue of ultra-Orthodox enlistment. It is not clear whether a proposed bill would pass legal muster. It does not seek to draft more ultra-Orthodox men into the military, but instead would cajole them into joining the workforce earlier.
The mayhem at the play centre in Harish, a mixed secular and religious town, made news reports as other signs of unease simmered.
In May, when singer Noa Kirel won third place in the Eurovision Song Contest, Israelis widely celebrated. But a powerful ultra-Orthodox member of Netanyahu's coalition, Moshe Gafni, brought up her name and referenced her revealing performance costume during a budget debate.
“I would also donate some clothes to her, so she can have some,” Gafni, the Finance Committee chairman, said. Kirel was quoted in Israeli media saying that everyone is entitled to their opinion.
Last month, outrage and threats of a boycott ensued when photos appeared on social media of purple stickers covering the faces of women on drugstore products at a leading pharmacy in the haredi city of Bnei Brak. Some ultra-Orthodox consider images of women to be immodest, and haredi media often erase the images of women from news photos. The pharmacy later stopped covering up women's photos.
Ultra-Orthodox Jews boycotted a bakery after one of its executives, a former government minister, supported the protests against the judiciary overhaul.
Just a few years ago, Harish had been promoted as a model of coexistence between its secular and religious residents. Now that seems like wishful thinking as a country long used to conflict with its outside neighbours finds itself grappling with unprecedented internal divisions.
“It's between Jews, that's the irony,” said Brayer Sharabi's husband, Avshalom, 39, in an interview outside the play centre. “What's happening now, feels new.”
(This story has not been edited by Devdiscourse staff and is auto-generated from a syndicated feed.)