Left Menu
Development News Edition

UPDATE 1-Swiss doctors urge COVID vulnerable to declare end-of-life wishes in advance

Pro Senectute Schweiz, an organisation for the elderly, said the doctors' appeal was premature and excessive but medics insist such patient decrees are necessary in the heart-wrenching reality of caring for critical patients during this pandemic. As health systems grapple with soaring infection rates, medical professionals working with limited resources and finite space in ICUs can at times face agonising dilemmas, and ethical questions around treating COVID-19 patients have spawned a government review in Britain and a court fight in Germany.

Reuters | Zurich | Updated: 22-11-2020 13:15 IST | Created: 22-11-2020 12:50 IST
UPDATE 1-Swiss doctors urge COVID vulnerable to declare end-of-life wishes in advance
Representative image Image Credit: ANI

Swiss doctors have urged those vulnerable to COVID-19 complications to record their wishes for end-of-life care in advance to help ease pressure on intensive care units, drawing criticism from an advocacy group. Pro Senectute Schweiz, an organisation for the elderly, said the doctors' appeal was premature and excessive but medics insist such patient decrees are necessary in the heart-wrenching reality of caring for critical patients during this pandemic.

As health systems grapple with soaring infection rates, medical professionals working with limited resources and finite space in ICUs can at times face agonising dilemmas, and ethical questions around treating COVID-19 patients have spawned a government review in Britain and a court fight in Germany. Warning that Switzerland was running low on intensive care beds, the Swiss Society for Intensive Care Medicine (SGI) called this week on the "especially imperiled", including people over 60, or with health conditions like heart disease and diabetes, to put their wishes on paper in case the worst should happen.

"This will support your own relatives, but also the teams in the ICUs, as they make decisions so the treatment can be done in the best possible manner according to the individual patient wishes," SGI said in a statement. Pro Senectute Schweiz said the call by the SGI, while in normal times sensible advice, created an impression of urgency inappropriate for a decision that demands deep consideration.

"The SGI appeal ... takes place in the context of an absolute emergency situation in which Switzerland does not yet find itself in," the group said. SGI president Thierry Fumeaux, an ICU doctor in the western Swiss city of Nyon, said the group was not aiming to put anyone under pressure or to free up beds, only to encourage them to think ahead.

"This is even more important in a time when vulnerable people are at high risk of having an infection, at high risk of being admitted to an ICU, and at high risk of dying," Fumeaux said. "This is not a call for sacrifice. It's just a call to take responsibility for their autonomy." Antonio Cuzzoli, who was head of intensive care at northern Italy's Cremona Hospital until July, said that as the coronavirus virus made the Lombardy region ground zero for infections in March and April, some patients committed "acts of heroism" by refusing treatment.

Italy has a "declaration of renouncement of invasive treatment", but some in the pre-dominantly Roman Catholic country may refuse it on the basis that it conflicts with their faith, Cuzzoli said. Still, some ICU doctors said the COVID-19 crisis has shown how making such a plan can spare unwanted suffering.

"It allows you not to take someone to the intensive care unit who, if he could have first had the choice, would have preferred not to end up (there)," Marco Vergano, an ICU doctor in Turin, said. "After a certain age and with comorbidities, ending up in intensive care is not a certain lifesaver, but can be a torture." In Switzerland, with its long history of legal assisted suicide, there may be less hesitation among people when it comes to making such personal decisions.

In October, Britain's Department of Health and Social Care asked the Care Quality Commission, which monitors and inspects hospitals and nursing homes, to review how so-called "Do not attempt cardiopulmonary resuscitation" (DNACPR) decisions were conducted during the pandemic. The review was launched in response to concerns that the elderly and vulnerable were being subjected to DNACPR decisions without their consent or given too little information to make an informed decision.

Emma Cave, a Durham University healthcare law professor who has written extensively about medical ethics, said the pandemic has intensified the dilemma of how to communicate with people at risk of COVID-19 about their options, should the worst occur. Nobody should face pressure, but refraining from talking with them may actually prevent them from getting treatment that matches their wishes, she said.

"The difficulty in waiting is that many patients would benefit from consultation," Cave said. "A failure to have such a conversation risks not respecting their views and breaching their rights." Ethical issues around prioritising treatment of COVID-19 patients are also in German courts, where a lawsuit over triage rules - when hospitals become so overloaded that they must choose whom to treat and whom to leave to die - is pending.

Plaintiffs with disabilities or underlying illness asked the Karlsruhe-based constitutional court to force the German government to establish such rules, fearing that otherwise they could be at a disadvantage. The court has expressed some doubts whether that this should be the government's role. In Switzerland, COVID-19 numbers have exploded during the second infection wave, rising from 100,000 weeks ago to more than 290,000 cases on Friday, when 4,946 new infections were recorded. The death toll is at 3,575.

In the French-speaking region near Lake Geneva where infection rates are among Europe's highest, some hospitals have shifted patients elsewhere via helicopter, including the country's German-speaking north where the infection rate is lower, to free up ICU space. So far, the system is stretched thin, but holding up, with spare ICU capacity in much of the country, official data shows.

"We are now under the 600 mark of hospitalised COVID patients," Bertrand Levrat, director of the Geneva University Hospital, told Reuters. "It's a good step, but we're far from relaxing."


TRENDING

OPINION / BLOG / INTERVIEW

Turbulence surrounding tobacco control in Ghana

... ...

Smart healthcare: IoT redefining the way healthcare is delivered

As the world is embracing the new wave of digitalization triggered by the pandemic and the arrival of 5G, the adoption of IoT devices will further boom. With adoption set to soar, IoT security issues and other challenges cant be ignored any...

Refugee compassion and response: Ideas to mitigate disasters now and in their future

Their homeland becomes a forbidden territory for them and more likely than not, their journey to foreign soil is no less traumatizing, not to say deadly. It is crucial to help refugees live a life of dignity and purpose....

Inadequate water infrastructure causes a tidal wave of coronavirus in rural Alaska

... ...

Videos

Latest News

‘Foundational and necessary change’ needed to heal post-COVID world

We need global solidarity and coordination, Secretary-General Antnio Guterres said at the event headlined, Rebirthing the Global Economy to Deliver Sustainable Development for All.He painted a grim picture of the havoc sparked by the pandem...

'Have lost an irreplaceable comrade': Sonia Gandhi on Ahmed Patel's demise

Congress president Sonia Gandhi on Wednesday condoled senior leader Ahmed Patels demise, saying she has lost an irreplaceable comrade, a faithful colleague and a friend whose entire life was dedicated to the partyPatel 71 passed away in the...

Experts adding support to help shape future of Māori broadcasting

A panel of seven experts are adding their support to help shape the future of Mori broadcasting, Minister for Mori Development Willie Jackson has announced today.Today I will meet with some of the most experienced Mori broadcasters, comment...

India's low-caste women raped to keep them 'in their place'

By Anuradha Nagaraj CHENNAI, India, Nov 25 Thomson Reuters Foundation - L ower-caste Dalit women in northern India are targeted for rape by upper caste men who usually escape justice as survivors bow to pressure to drop their cases, researc...

Give Feedback