Left Menu
Development News Edition

U.S. appeals court judges spar with Trump lawyer over bid to block House subpoena

Reuters | Washington DC | Updated: 12-07-2019 22:51 IST | Created: 12-07-2019 22:48 IST
U.S. appeals court judges spar with Trump lawyer over bid to block House subpoena
Image Credit: ANI

A U.S. appeals court on Friday appeared unlikely to grant President Donald Trump's request that it block a congressional subpoena for his financial records.

The U.S. Court of Appeals for the District of Columbia Circuit heard oral arguments in a lawsuit Trump filed arguing his accounting firm, Mazars LLP, does not need to comply with a House of Representatives Oversight Committee subpoena. The three judges on the panel did not say how or when they would rule. But they repeatedly sparred with Trump's personal lawyer William Consovoy over his central argument that the subpoena is unconstitutional because it is "law enforcement" that would not further Congress' main task of enacting laws.

Judge David Tatel said the House is already working on legislation relating to presidential conflicts of interest and government ethics and suggested that the financial records requested from Mazars are reasonably related to that effort. "These bills have passed the House and are directly related to the subject of this subpoena," Tatel said.

The House Oversight Committee has also said it needs Trump's financial records to examine whether he broke the law by not disentangling himself from his business holdings, as previous presidents have done. But Consovoy urged the judges to look at the "totality of the evidence," including media reports that House Speaker Nancy Pelosi told fellow Democrats that she wants to see Trump in prison.

Consovoy said Pelosi's remark makes clear that Congress' real objective with the Mazars subpoena is to investigate Trump so it can make him look bad and score political points. "The court does not have to be naive ... and deny what is staring the court in its face," Consovoy said.

Judge Patricia Millett told Consovoy she was wary of second-guessing Congress' motives. If she adopted his argument, she would be essentially calling the House's proposed ethics laws "a ruse" for getting Trump's financial records, she said. "Can we do that?" Millett asked, noting that courts have long been reluctant to block congressional subpoenas.

Mazars has avoided taking sides in the dispute and said it will "comply with all legal obligations." In August an appeals court in New York will hear oral arguments in a challenge Trump brought seeking to block similar congressional subpoenas issued to Deutsche Bank AG and Capital One Financial Corp.

Trump is refusing to cooperate with a series of investigations on issues ranging from his tax returns and policy decisions to his Washington hotel and his children's security clearances.


TRENDING

OPINION / BLOG / INTERVIEW

5G will be the key driving force for COVID-19 recovery: Here's how?

... ...

Canada’s COVID-19 pitfalls highlight need for integrated health information system

In the globalized world of today where outbreaks can spread far and wide within a matter of days, a global-level integrated health information system is ideal but Canadas provincial barriers show that the country lags much behind in deployi...

Pandemic must be impetus, not obstacle, for clean water access

To make matters worse, there are suspicions that the inadequacy of wastewater treatment methods in California, the rest of the USA, and indeed around the world may help to propagate the disease even more widely. ...

3D printing and the future of manufacturing post COVID-19

The on-demand, customizable, and localized manufacturing of product components facilitated by 3D printing has the potential to redefine manufacturing but there are certain technical, mechanical, and legal limitations that, unless ...

Videos

Latest News

Members of AISA, other groups protesting Hany Babu arrest booked for flouting prohibiting orders

The Delhi Police has registered a case against members of Left-affiliated AISA and other organisations for flouting prohibitory orders while protesting the arrest of Delhi University professor Hany Babu by the NIA in the Bhima Koregaon-Elga...

NBA issues memo banning 'casual relationship' visitors in bubble

When conference semifinals begin in the 2020 NBA playoffs, spouses and families will be permitted in the bubble near Orlando. The NBA, however, is looking to set guidelines for player guests that fall into the other classification, such as ...

India's COVID-19 cases breach the 23 lakh-mark; recovery rate stands at 70.38 pc

India reported a spike of 60,963 COVID-19 cases in the last 24 hours, taking the national count over the 23 lakh-mark, as per the Union Health Ministry on Wednesday. Ministry of Health and Family Welfare, Government of India MoHFW further i...

One-of-a-kind baseball card goes up for auction for $1 million

A modern but unique signed baseball card featuring Mike Trout of the Los Angeles Angels has been put up for auction - with bidding starting at a cool 1 million. Vintage baseball cards have long been seen as collectibles, with a record 3.1 m...

Give Feedback