Foreign private FDI equal to Aid in many Asian & African nations: CGD Research

Much of the new investment in Africa, where most low-income countries are located, is coming from China. China more than doubled its total foreign direct investment in the continent between 2011 and 2016—and the amount is now closing in on that of the largest traditional western investors like the US, UK, and France, which have mostly stayed flat over that same time period.

The foreign private investment now supplies about as much finance as foreign aid in many low-income countries in Africa and Asia, according to a study published on Thursday by the Center for Global Development (CGD), Washington.

The study examined foreign private capital flows—meaning foreign direct investment (FDI), portfolio equity and debt, and bank and other lendings—to low-income countries, a group of 27 countries primarily in Asia and Africa. It was found that for the median low-income countries, the ratio of foreign private investment to GDP is about the same as the ratio of foreign aid to GDP.

"This was a surprise," said Nancy Lee, a senior policy fellow at CGD, a former senior official at the Millennium Challenge Corporation, and the lead author of the study. "We thought that foreign private capital flows would not contribute much to invest in low-income countries, especially after the global financial crisis. Instead, we found that these private capital flows are a major source of finance—and they've mostly increased since the financial crisis. That's in contrast to aid, which has declined sharply as a share of GDP." "Most of these inflows are in the form of FDI, which is a more stable, less volatile source of finance," she continued. "That's good news for these economies."

Some more interesting findings of the study

It's not all about natural resources

These investments are not all captured by resource-rich countries. In 2017, more than half of capital inflows went to countries that are not rich in oil or other natural resources. "It's increasingly clear that policies, not just resource endowments, shape FDI destinations for low-income countries," Lee said.

China is a growing investor, not just a lender

Much of the new investment in Africa, where most low-income countries are located, is coming from China. China more than doubled its total foreign direct investment in the continent between 2011 and 2016—and the amount is now closing in on that of the largest traditional western investors like the US, UK, and France, which have mostly stayed flat over that same time period.

"There's been a lot of focus on China's role as a lender to African countries, but China has also emerged as one of the most important investors in Africa," Lee said. "It's clearly making a long-term commitment to the region."

But foreign and domestic investment are not mutually reinforcing

Low-income countries with higher rates of private foreign investment don't tend to have higher rates of private domestic investment. That raises concerns, said the authors of the study.

"We would expect foreign and domestic private investment to be complementary, as is the case in lower-middle-income countries," Lee said. "But we're not seeing that pattern in low-income countries. They need to think about how to spread the benefits of foreign investment more widely in the economy."

Policies make a difference

Foreign investors care about the policy environment for investment. The study finds a significant positive relationship between foreign investment/GDP and the perceived quality of the regulatory environment in low-income countries without resource riches.

"Foreign aid is still important for poor countries, but private investment is already as big and growing. That's especially true for FDI to non-resource-rich countries. These countries are showing that their resource endowments no longer determine their destiny. Their policy choices matter," Lee said.

Note: The study covered 27 countries: Afghanistan, Bangladesh, Benin, Burkina Faso, Burundi, Cambodia, Democratic Republic of Congo, Ethiopia, Guinea, Haiti, Kenya, Kyrgyz Republic, Liberia, Madagascar, Malawi, Mali, Mozambique, Myanmar, Nepal, Niger, Sierra Leone, South Sudan, Tajikistan, Tanzania, Togo, Uganda, and Zimbabwe.