Left Menu
Development News Edition

An impartial judge should not hesitate to recuse if there are reasonable grounds: SC

PTI | New Delhi | Updated: 14-08-2019 19:43 IST | Created: 14-08-2019 19:43 IST
An impartial judge should not hesitate to recuse if there are reasonable grounds: SC

An impartial judge should not hesitate to recuse himself from a case if there are just and reasonable grounds, the Supreme Court said on Wednesday. Rejecting a plea seeking recusal of a judge, a bench comprising justices A M Khanwilkar and Ajay Rastogi said it was always open to a judge to recuse from a case at his own will.

"Indubitably, it is always open for a judge to recuse at his own volition from a case entrusted to him by the Chief Justice. But, that may be a matter of his own choosing. Recusal, at the asking of the litigating party, cannot be countenanced unless it deserves due consideration and is justified.... "It must never be forgotten that an impartial judge is the quintessence for a fair trial and one should not hesitate to recuse if there are just and reasonable grounds. At the same time, one cannot be oblivious of the duty of a judge, which is to discharge his responsibility with absolute earnestness, sincerity and being true to the oath of his/her office," the bench said.

The top court was hearing an appeal filed by advocate Seema Sapra against a Delhi High Court judgment holding her guilty of contempt of court and imposing a punishment of a month-long jail term along with fine. The petitioner had sought recusal of Justice Khanwilkar from hearing the matter as she had alleged that he was well acquainted with the lawyers, who incidentally are members of the Supreme Court Bar Association and against whom she had levelled personal allegations.

The apex court, however, said after a perusal of the submissions, it had no hesitation in observing that the assertions were devoid of merit and without any substance. With regard to the appeal against the finding of guilt and imposition of punishment under the Contempt of Courts Act, the apex court stayed the high court judgment.

"The appellant has prayed for stay of operation of the impugned judgment and order pending hearing and decision on this appeal. As it appears from the record that the two-year period for which the appellant has been restrained from appearing in the High Court of Delhi and the courts subordinate thereunder in terms of the impugned judgment is already over, nevertheless we consider it appropriate to stay the effect of the impugned judgment and order dated December 17, 2015 until disposal of the appeal," the bench said.


TRENDING

OPINION / BLOG / INTERVIEW

South Africa's COVID-19 response: Surprising outcomes or just poor data management?

South Africa has been committed to improving its health information system and shows that a robust digital has considerable scope to improve healthcare for the entire population. But the COVID-19 pandemic has highlighted that significant ga...

Post-COVID-19 Nigeria needs a robust Health Management Information System to handle high disease burden

Nigeria is among a few countries that conceptualised a health management information system HMIS in the early 90s but implementation has been a challenge till date. Besides COVID-19, the country has a huge burden of communicable and non-com...

Morocco COVID-19 response: A fragile health system and the deteriorating situation

Learning from its European neighbors, Morocco imposed drastic measures from the initial stages of the COVID-19 outbreak to try to contain its spread. The strategy worked for a few months but the cases have surged after mid-June. In this sit...

COVID-19: Argentina’s health system inefficiencies exaggerate flaws of health information system

You can recover from a drop in the GDP, but you cant recover from death, was the straightforward mindset of Argentinas President Alberto Fernndez and defined the countrys response to COVID-19. The South American nation imposed a strict...

Videos

Latest News

Pakistani soldiers fighting alongside Azerbaijan troops

Pakistani soldiers are allegedly fighting alongside the Azerbaijan troops in Agdam, according to a telephonic conversation between two civilians, posted by Free News.AM. During the telephonic conversation, two Azerbaijanis were speaking abo...

Fresh Armenia-Azerbaijan clashes over Nagorno-Karabakh, as UN chief urges an end to fighting

According to news reports, at least 16 people have been killed along the line of contact in the worst fighting between the two former Soviet Republics in four years.Secretary-General antonioguterres voices extreme concern over the fresh r...

Ahead of biodiversity summit, UN officials call for action to preserve the natural world

We have no time to wait. Biodiversity loss, nature loss, it is at an unprecedented level in the history of mankind, Elizabeth Mrema, the Executive Secretary of the Convention on Biological Diversity, told UN News in the SDG Media Zone. We...

India: UN expert raises alarm over mass evictions of Delhi railway track dwellers

Balakrishnan Rajagopal, UN Special Rapporteur on adequate housing, also said that none of those affected, appeared to have been consulted or heard by the Court beforehand, and that the judges had initially ruled that no one should be allo...

Give Feedback