Left Menu
Development News Edition

Serious injury not only permanently imposes disabilities but inflicts deep emotional scars: SC

In addition to loss of future earnings (based on a determination of the income at the time of accident), the appellant is entitled for loss of future prospects. “It needs to be underlined that Courts should be mindful that a serious injury not only permanently imposes physical limitations and disabilities but too often inflicts deep mental and emotional scars upon the victim.

PTI | New Delhi | Updated: 18-09-2020 16:43 IST | Created: 18-09-2020 16:43 IST
Serious injury not only permanently imposes disabilities but inflicts deep emotional scars: SC

The Supreme Court has enhanced the compensation to a victim of road accident saying that courts should be mindful that a serious injury not only imposes disabilities but also inflicts deep mental and emotional scars.  The apex court said it has emphasised time and again that “just compensation” should include all elements that would go to place the victim in as near a position as she or he was in, before the occurrence of the accident.  Whilst no amount of money or other material compensation can erase the trauma, pain and suffering that a victim undergoes after a serious accident, monetary compensation assures some measure of restitution, the apex court said. The high court had awarded a compensation of Rs 7,77,600 but the apex court enhanced it to Rs 19,65,600 considering the enhancement towards loss of earning capacity and future prospects. The top court was hearing an appeal filed by Pappu Deo Yadav who was working as a data entry operator/typist at Tis Hazari Courts and he earned a salary of Rs 12,000 per month.

The appellant, who had claimed a compensation of Rs 50 lakh, had incurred permanent disability, which was assessed to be 89 per cent.  The Motor Accident Claims Tribunal and the High Court re-assessed the disability to be only 45 per cent on the assumption that the assessment for compensation was to be on a different basis, as the injury entailed loss of only one arm. The apex court said the Delhi High Court clearly erred in holding that compensation for loss of future prospects could not be awarded. In addition to loss of future earnings (based on a determination of the income at the time of accident), the appellant is entitled for loss of future prospects.

“It needs to be underlined that Courts should be mindful that a serious injury not only permanently imposes physical limitations and disabilities but too often inflicts deep mental and emotional scars upon the victim.  “The attendant trauma of the victim's having to live in a world entirely different from the one she or he is born into, as an invalid, and with degrees of dependence on others, robbed of complete personal choice or autonomy, should forever be in the judge's mind, whenever tasked to adjudge compensation claims,” a bench, comprising Justices L Nageswara Rao, Krishna Murari and S Ravindra Bhat,  said. Holding that severe limitations inflicted due to injuries undermine the dignity of the individual, the top court said it deprives the person of the essence of the right to a wholesome life.

“From the world of the able bodied, the victim is thrust into the world of the disabled, itself most discomfiting and unsettling.  “If courts nit-pick and award niggardly amounts oblivious of these circumstances, there is resultant affront to the injured victim,” the bench said..


TRENDING

OPINION / BLOG / INTERVIEW

New farm bills in India: Focusing on farms or farmers?

... ...

Kenya’s COVID-19 response: Chaos amid lack of information

Confusing numbers and scanty information on how effective curfews and lockdowns have been in breaking transmission have amplified coordination and planning challenges in Kenyas response to COVID-19. Without accurate data, it is impossible t...

Farkhad Akhmedov: Calculating the price of impunity from the law

In insistences such as the battle over the Luna, Akhmedov has resorted to extreme legal machinations to subvert the High Courts decision and keep his assets from being seized. ...

Guinea’s elections hearken back to the autocracy and violence of its past

... ...

Videos

Latest News

PRESS DIGEST- Financial Times - Oct 22

The following are the top stories in the Financial Times. Reuters has not verified these stories and does not vouch for their accuracy. HeadlinesUK and EU to resume talks in final push for post-Brexit trade deal httpson.ft.com37xtDTISunak s...

U.S. envoy secretly met associate of Venezuela's Maduro on peaceful exit but no deal -sources

A senior Trump administration envoy met secretly with a representative of Venezuelan President Nicolas Maduro last month to try to work out Maduros peaceful exit from power, but no agreement was reached, three people familiar with the matte...

Republicans to push ahead with U.S. Supreme Court pick despite Democrats' boycott

U.S. Senate Republicans pledged to go ahead with a vote on Thursday on President Donald Trumps Supreme Court nominee, Amy Coney Barrett, despite Judiciary Committee Democrats pledging to boycott a proceeding that they called a sham. Senate ...

US proposes not to issue business visas for H-1B speciality occupations

The US State Department in a federal notification Wednesday proposed to make changes to its existing visa regulations under which foreign professionals, which would fall under H-1B, would not be issued temporary visa for business, as has be...

Give Feedback