Left Menu
Development News Edition

Judge: Justice Dept reversal in Flynn case 'unusual'

PTI | Washington DC | Updated: 02-06-2020 03:32 IST | Created: 02-06-2020 03:18 IST
Judge: Justice Dept reversal in Flynn case 'unusual'
Representative Image Image Credit: ANI

A judge on Monday defended his decision not to quickly approve the Justice Department's request to dismiss its own criminal case against former Trump administration national security adviser Michael Flynn, saying that the department's reversal in the case was unusual and he wanted to carefully consider the request before ruling on it. The brief from US District Judge Emmet Sullivan offers the most detailed explanation for his refusal to immediately sign off on the department's decision to drop its case against Flynn, who pleaded guilty as part of special counsel Robert Mueller's Russia investigation.

It raises the prospect for a drawn-out clash between two branches of government over whether a judge can be forced to unwind a guilty plea at the Justice Department's behest. Flynn's attorneys have urged the Washington-based federal appeals court to order Sullivan to grant the department's request. But Sullivan laid out in detail his reasons for his concern as he urged the appeals court to stay out of the case until he has a chance to study the dismissal request, which he said he may ultimately grant.

"The question before this Court is whether it should short-circuit this process, forbid even a limited inquiry into the government's motion, and order that motion granted," lawyers for Sullivan wrote. "The answer is no. " Flynn admitted lying to the FBI about having discussed sanctions during the presidential transition with the then-Russian ambassador, a topic recently released transcripts of the call show the men talked about in detail. But the Justice Department said last month that the FBI should never have interviewed Flynn in the first place and that the communication he had with the ambassador was entirely appropriate. Flynn enjoys strong support from Trump and the conservative media, but the decision to drop the case outraged former law enforcement officials who were involved in the investigation as well as many Democrats.

Rather than grant the request, Sullivan appointed a retired federal judge, John Gleeson, to argue against the Justice Department's position and to consider whether Flynn could be held in criminal contempt for perjury since he had previously pleaded guilty under oath to lying and was now saying otherwise. He also invited outside parties to weigh in. In their brief Monday, Sullivan's lawyers cited what they said were numerous irregularities about the case, noting that "it is unusual for a criminal defendant to claim innocence and move to withdraw his guilty plea after repeatedly swearing under oath that he committed the crime." Beyond that, they said, "It is unprecedented for an Acting US Attorney to contradict the solemn representations that career prosecutors made time and again, and undermine the district court's legal and factual findings, in moving on his own to dismiss the charge years after two different federal judges accepted the defendant's plea".

The judge's brief also noted that the Justice Department's motion to dismiss the case was not signed by any of the career prosecutors involved in the case, and cited "minimal legal authority" for its positions. Though Sullivan may ultimately grant the Justice Department's motion, he was duty-bound to seriously consider the significant legal issues that the case raised, it said.


TRENDING

OPINION / BLOG / INTERVIEW

COVID-19 seems cooking biggest ever global scam

The increasing number of corruption cases on COVID-19 funds from throughout the world and involvement of high profile persons indicate that the countries cant ignore corruption in their pandemic response programs. This has generated the nee...

Health Management Information Systems lack holistic, integrated, and pandemic resilient character

Being a part of the United Nations system, the World Health Organization WHO deserves its share of rebuke for its alleged failure issue COVID-19 health emergency alerts on appropriate time. However, the pandemic has also exposed loopholes i...

Pride in the time of coronavirus: a welcome move online?

This year is different in many ways not least as celebrations are also taking place against the dramatic backdrop of a global health crisis and a resurgence in grassroots activism following the death of George Floyd in Minneapolis. ...

COVID-19: Weighing up the benefits and limitations of edtech platforms

Edtech companies shouldnt focus on merely pushing contents, but to provide an interactive, effective teaching and learning environment. ...

Videos

Latest News

US military to stand with India in conflict with China, indicates WH official

The US military will continue to stand strong in relationship to a conflict between India and China or anywhere else, a top White House official said on Monday, after the US Navy deployed two aircraft carriers to the South China Sea to boos...

Karachi garment factory inferno act of terrorism: probe report

The fire at a garment factory in Karachis Baldia town in September 2012 that killed 289 people was an act of organised terrorism and not an accident, according to a probe report released by the Sindh government in Pakistan on Monday. Accord...

Nationals GM: Workout off, season 'at risk' without MLB intervention

A scheduled Monday workout was canceled by the Washington Nationals as a precaution as they await results of teamwide coronavirus testing. Nationals president and general manager Mike Rizzo said all players and staff were tested Friday and ...

Tell-all book by Trump's niece gets earlier release date

A tell-all book by U.S. President Donald Trumps niece will be published on July 14, two weeks earlier than expected, its publisher Simon Schuster Inc said on Monday.The decision comes days after a New York state court lifted a judges rulin...

Give Feedback