Left Menu
Development News Edition

Push to formalise land claims may even lead to greater rights abuses - analysts

Rina Chandran - Reuters | Updated: 15-03-2019 10:10 IST | Created: 15-03-2019 09:35 IST
Push to formalise land claims may even lead to greater rights abuses - analysts
Image Credit: Twitter(@SAgovnews)

A push to formalise land claims, map settlements and digitise records is not always in the best interests of vulnerable communities, and may even lead to greater rights abuses, analysts warned on Friday.

From Peru to the Philippines, governments are curtailing the rights of indigenous communities and forcibly resettling people in slums, land campaigners say, while mapping lands and digitising land records with the aim of increasing efficiency. But despite the benefits to formality, there is also the risk of further marginalising vulnerable communities, said Chamundeeswari Kuppuswamy, a professor at Britain's Hertfordshire Law School.

"With formality comes greater certainty and predictability, and more efficient transactions. But you have to be careful that it's not done by force or in a rush," she said on the sidelines of a land conference in New Delhi. "There are limits to how much formality you can have. But if the ideology is that technology makes everything formal and foolproof, then you may impinge on the rights of the vulnerable," she told the Thomson Reuters Foundation.

Indigenous and local communities own more than half of all land under customary rights, yet have secure legal rights to just 10 percent, according to advocacy group Rights and Resources Initiative. But making their claims formal and their land visible - through mapping and open data - may not always be a good idea, said Christine Richter, an assistant professor at the University of Twente in the Netherlands.

"With indigenous communities, the importance of keeping a place sacred is keeping it secret," she said. In the case of informal land use, while making visible to a wider audience where people live can legitimise and support their land claims, it can also be used to justify that they need to be moved because they are on a floodplain, she said. "So you have to ask: what role does visibility and invisibility through data and through mapping play, in protecting or not protecting the place and the people? And who decides who remains visible or invisible?" About a fourth of the world's urban population lives in informal settlements, according to UN-Habitat, the United Nations' human settlements programme.

By making their claims public, these communities may be at greater risk of eviction or exposed to criminal elements, said Frank Pichel, chief programmes officer at Cadasta Foundation, a Washington-based non-profit that develops digital tools to document and analyse land data. While collecting data and opening up access to it can lead to greater efficiency in land administration, increased prosperity, and greater accountability, communities must also be able to assess the potential risks, he said. "Community feedback - and consent - is essential to determining what data on land should be open," he said. "It ends up being a long conversation about national and international standards and assessing the risks. But it's a necessary conversation."

(This story has not been edited by Devdiscourse staff and is auto-generated from a syndicated feed.)

Download The Devdiscourse News App for Latest News.


TRENDING

OPINION / BLOG / INTERVIEW

Diya Jalao for COVID 19: How Modi put Power Grids and power warriors at risk?

While Prime Minister Narendra Modis staunch supporters are busy in search of hidden science behind the sudden announcement of 9minutes9pm campaign but his ignorance of the actual science has put the nation in another danger. The scientists ...

Energy markets post-COVID 19: Recovery may take time, transition to continue

As oil markets have crashed, the experts believe the oil prices will come down drastically and continue making the energy transition a financial burden for many economies for a couple of years.  However, the market alone was never...

'Diya jalao' for COVID 19: Modi needs to practice his teachings and control fake news on social media

In his video message to the nation on Friday the Prime Minister talks about peoples collective power to win the invincible. However, he has made no concreate efforts to win over the confidence and represent the collective power of the polit...

Tourism post-COVID 19: Lessons learned, out-of-box strategies to ensure the revival

In the pre-COVID 19 period the tourism industry was seen with much hope throughout the world. However, the COVID 19 pandemic has completely paralysed the tourism industry and its dependent sectors. The tourism industry in the post-COVID 19 ...

Videos

Latest News

China reports 30 new coronavirus cases; nine districts in Wuhan classified as ‘low-risk’

China has reported 30 new cases of the novel coronavirus, including five locally transmitted infections, even as nine of the 13 administrative districts of virus-hit Wuhan city were declared low-risk areas signifying a gradual return to nor...

AIIMS Raipur to receive 10,000 medical protection kits

All India Institute of Medical Sciences AIIMS, Raipur is set to receive 10,000 more Personnel Protective Equipment PPE kits amid the COVID-19 pandemic. Raipur Lok Sabha MP Sunil Soni visited Virus Research and Diagnostic Lab at AIIMS Raipur...

Test spinner Stephen O'Keefe retires from 1st class cricket

Former Australia Test spinner Stephen OKeefe has retired from first class cricket after being omitted from New South Wales list of contracted players for the next domestic season. The 35-year-old left-armer, who took 35 wickets in nine test...

Lucknow Cantonment area sealed for 48 hrs after 12 Tablighi Jamaat returnees test positive for COVID-19

Lucknow Cantonment area was sealed for 48 hours after 12 Tablighi Jamaat returnees in Sadar Bazaar area tested positive for COVID-19. Only Quick Response Teams and medical teams will be allowed entry into the area.A total of 1,302 people, w...

Give Feedback