Left Menu
Development News Edition

San Francisco officials let people sue over racist 911 calls

Fed up with white people calling 911 about people of colour selling water bottles, barbecuing or otherwise going about their lives, San Francisco leaders unanimously approved hate crime legislation giving the targets of those calls the ability to sue the caller.

PTI | Sanfrancisco | Updated: 21-10-2020 10:07 IST | Created: 21-10-2020 10:07 IST
San Francisco officials let people sue over racist 911 calls

Fed up with white people calling 911 about people of colour selling water bottles, barbecuing or otherwise going about their lives, San Francisco leaders unanimously approved hate crime legislation giving the targets of those calls the ability to sue the caller. The Board of Supervisors voted Tuesday on the Caution Against Racial and Exploitative Non-Emergencies Act, also known as the CAREN legislation. It's a nod to a popular meme using the name “Karen” to describe an entitled white woman whose actions stem from her privilege, such as using police to target people of colour.

All 11 supervisors signed on to the legislation, guaranteeing its passage, despite criticism that the name is sexist and divisive. It comes amid a national reckoning on race sparked by the police killings of Black Americans and instances where white people called for officers to investigate people of colour. “We don't want what happened to Emmett Till in 1955, or the long history of false accusations of black men and boys in this country, due to weaponizing law enforcement, to threaten, terrorize, and sometimes even kill them, to ever happen again,” said Supervisor Shamann Walton, who introduced the legislation and is Black.

“I really want to emphasize that 911 is not a customer service line for someone's racist behavior," he said. Walton was the only supervisor to speak. Till was a Black teenager beaten to death in 1955 after accusations by a white woman who later admitted to lying.

In May, Amy Cooper, a white woman, called 911 from Manhattan's Central Park, falsely claiming that a Black man — who had politely asked her to leash her dog — was threatening her. She has been charged with filing a false police report. In San Francisco, a white couple was criticized on social media after video was widely shared of them questioning a Filipino American stenciling “Black Lives Matter” on a retaining wall in front of his home in June. They later called police.

James Juanillo said he chose yellow chalk to match the colour of the house. When the couple approached him, they repeatedly demanded to know if it was his home because he was defacing private property. “They tried to cast it as a criminal scene,” he said. “It was me calmly applying chalk, not spray paint, not in the middle of the night but very deliberately. The only thing that was missing was a pinot grigio.” Supporters of the legislation say it is crushing to be confronted by police because someone saw you as a threat, possibly as a criminal or as not belonging. It's especially terrifying for Black people, whose encounters with police could end in violence.

“This is not hyperbole," said Brittni Chicuata, chief of staff for San Francisco's Human Rights Commission. “This is an established pattern reflected in the disparate treatment of Black people and other people of colour in our city and in our country." Other places have moved to make placing racist 911 calls a hate crime. California's governor recently signed a measure making the crime a misdemeanor punishable by jail time and a fine. New York approved legislation allowing the victims of racist 911 calls to sue. The San Francisco legislation gives people the right to sue a 911 caller in civil court, and supporters hope it will make some think twice before turning to police. The discrimination need not be only racial; it can also be due to the person's sex, age, religion, disability, gender identity, weight or height.

The legislation does not spell out the standards needed to sue. But it notes that qualifying calls are those that caused the person to feel harassed or embarrassed; damaged the person's reputation or business prospects; or forced the person from an area where they had a lawful right to be. The board has received written complaints from eight people — several whose names have different spellings of Karen — saying they support the legislation but object to its moniker, which they call sexist and ageist.it Vic Vicari wrote that the insensitive use of the name “as a general purpose term of disapproval for middle age white women needs to stop.” Carynn Silva said she loves the name her mom gave her and called it a racist term against white women. Caren Batides asked if the supervisor would want his name mocked.

“Yes, I am named Karen, and I do speak up for injustices on a regular occasion,” Karen Shane wrote. “So could we attempt at coming up with some other acronym that doesn't vilify a whole group of people named Karen/Caryn/Caren?” Reached by phone, Shane, who lives in a San Francisco Bay Area suburb and describes herself as a middle-aged white woman, readily pokes fun at her first name and said she's aware that even complaining about it is something that a “Karen” would do. But she feels the supervisor didn't need to cheapen what she agrees is important legislation. “By using the name CAREN, he's just perpetuating a racial divide," she said. “Granted it's not a protected class, but it's somebody's name.” Walton has dismissed the concerns, saying the legislation does not refer to any individual.


TRENDING

OPINION / BLOG / INTERVIEW

Turbulence surrounding tobacco control in Ghana

... ...

Smart healthcare: IoT redefining the way healthcare is delivered

As the world is embracing the new wave of digitalization triggered by the pandemic and the arrival of 5G, the adoption of IoT devices will further boom. With adoption set to soar, IoT security issues and other challenges cant be ignored any...

Refugee compassion and response: Ideas to mitigate disasters now and in their future

Their homeland becomes a forbidden territory for them and more likely than not, their journey to foreign soil is no less traumatizing, not to say deadly. It is crucial to help refugees live a life of dignity and purpose....

Inadequate water infrastructure causes a tidal wave of coronavirus in rural Alaska

... ...

Videos

Latest News

WB govt will soon start free ambulance service for road accident victims: Official

To help save lives of road accident victims by taking them to nearby hospitals as quickly as possible, the West Bengal government will soon start a free-ambulance service, a senior official of the state health department said on Monday. Sta...

Pak violates ceasefire in J-K's Poonch

Pakistan violated ceasefire along the Line of Control LoC in the Shahpur sector of Poonch district here on Monday.According to sources, small arms were fired and there was intense shelling with mortars at around 310 pm.Indian Army retaliate...

The June Shop celebrates its first anniversary with fashionable must-haves ~Your one-stop-shop for everything quirky, fashionable and affordable~

The June Shop is an e-commerce brand conceptualised in the year 2019 by Rishav Nahata and Pranav Jain to fulfil the need for affordable gifting in the Indian market. The June Shop TJS is Indias one-stop-shop to satisfy your everyday need fo...

Credit card inquiries in Oct surpass year-ago figures: Transunion Cibil

Banks requests for information on credit card borrowers or credit card inquiries in October surpassed the same in the year-ago period, a credit information company said on Monday. This phenomenon suggests consumer economic activity has mate...

Give Feedback