Left Menu
Development News Edition

Judge refuses to block 'No Boycott of Israel' measure

Ali's lawsuit said Hogan's order bars him from bidding for government software program contracts because he supports boycotts of businesses and organizations that “contribute to the oppression of Palestinians.” But Ali hasn't submitted any bids, so Blake ruled Monday that he cannot proceed on the basis of a “direct injury.” Last October, the judge initially dismissed Mr. Ali's complaint “without prejudice,” meaning he could refile the case.

PTI | Collegepark | Updated: 27-10-2020 09:24 IST | Created: 27-10-2020 06:13 IST
Judge refuses to block 'No Boycott of Israel' measure

A federal judge on Monday threw out a lawsuit in which a Muslim civil rights group sought to block the state of Maryland from enforcing its ban on contracting with businesses that boycott Israel. US District Judge Catherine Blake didn't reach a decision on whether the executive order that Maryland Gov Larry Hogan signed in October 2017 is constitutional. The judge ruled that a software engineer who is named as the lawsuit's plaintiff hasn't shown he has suffered any "direct injury" giving him the legal standing to challenge the order.

Hogan's order requires contractors to certify in writing that they don't boycott Israel. The order was called "Prohibiting Discriminatory Boycotts of Israel in State Procurement." The Council on American-Islamic Relations sued Hogan and state Attorney General Brian Frosh on behalf of software engineer Syed Saqib Ali, a former state legislator. CAIR argued the order has an unconstitutional chilling effect on First Amendment-protected political advocacy supporting the Palestinians. The executive order says a boycott based on religion, national origin, or ethnicity is discriminatory. A business boycott of Israel and its territories "is not a commercial decision made for business or economic reasons," it says.

"Contracting with business entities that discriminate make the State a passive participant in private-sector commercial discrimination," the order says. Ali's lawsuit said Hogan's order bars him from bidding for government software program contracts because he supports boycotts of businesses and organizations that "contribute to the oppression of Palestinians." But Ali hasn't submitted any bids, so Blake ruled Monday that he cannot proceed on the basis of a "direct injury." Last October, the judge initially dismissed Mr. Ali's complaint "without prejudice," meaning he could refile the case. In that ruling, the judge said Ali would have to plausibly show that his First Amendment free speech rights had been violated.

Ali filed an amended complaint later that month, claiming Hogan's order violates his constitutional rights to freedom of speech and assembly. He also claimed the order and the mandated "No Boycott of Israel" certification in Maryland bids and contracts are unconstitutionally vague. In Monday's ruling, the judge said Ali hasn't shown that his free speech has been "chilled" by the certification requirement or that he engaged in any self-censorship.

"Mr Ali has not presented any allegations that he has ceased any boycotting activities that would be covered by the Executive Order or that but for the certification, he would have expanded his boycotting activities," she wrote. Blake also said Ali doesn't allege that he boycotts Israel in his business capacity, except possibly for one sentence in a court filing that says he "will continue to refuse to do business with, for instance, American citizens who operate in the West Bank." "Other than this," the judge wrote, "Mr. Ali does not allege that he intends to participate in any activities that would be covered under the Executive Order, and it is not clear from Mr Ali's amended complaint that any of his potential work for the state — were he to bid on and obtain a contract — would require him to work with other businesses." In January 2019, when it filed the initial version of the suit, CAIR said 25 other states had enacted measures similar to Maryland's through legislation or executive orders.

Raquel Coombs, a spokeswoman for the attorney general's office, declined to comment on the judge's ruling. Ali, a resident of Gaithersburg, served as a member of the Maryland House of Delegates from 2007 to 2011 and represented Montgomery County as a Democrat. He accused Hogan, a Republican, of making an "end around" the Legislature by signing the executive order after lawmakers repeatedly rejected several "anti-BDS" bills targeting the Palestinian-led Boycott, Divestment, and Sanctions movement.


TRENDING

OPINION / BLOG / INTERVIEW

Turbulence surrounding tobacco control in Ghana

... ...

Smart healthcare: IoT redefining the way healthcare is delivered

As the world is embracing the new wave of digitalization triggered by the pandemic and the arrival of 5G, the adoption of IoT devices will further boom. With adoption set to soar, IoT security issues and other challenges cant be ignored any...

Refugee compassion and response: Ideas to mitigate disasters now and in their future

Their homeland becomes a forbidden territory for them and more likely than not, their journey to foreign soil is no less traumatizing, not to say deadly. It is crucial to help refugees live a life of dignity and purpose....

Inadequate water infrastructure causes a tidal wave of coronavirus in rural Alaska

... ...

Videos

Latest News

Beyonce dominates surprise Grammy field, marked by snub for The Weeknd

Beyonce dominated nominations for the 2021 Grammy Awards on Tuesday in a field that mostly favored alternative artists over mainstream musicians, topped by a stunning snub for Canadian singer The Weeknd. Beyonces leading nine nods made her ...

Trump hails Dow Jones Industrial Average crossing record 30,000 mark

In a brief speech, US President Donald Trump congratulated the public on the Dow Jones Industrial Average hitting a historic record of 30,000 points. I just want to congratulate everybody. The stock market Dow Jones Industrial Average just ...

FACTBOX-Latest on worldwide spread of the coronavirus

Officials beseeched Americans to stay at home and redouble efforts to curtail the pandemic, while governments across Europe tried to navigate a fine line between avoiding super-spreading the virus and allowing families to celebrate Christma...

Dozens of Venezuelan migrants arrive in Trinidad after hours at sea

At least 29 Venezuelan migrants, including 16 minors, returned to Trinidad and Tobago on Tuesday after being deported from the island over the weekend and spending hours at sea, said their relatives, who had been concerned about their where...

Give Feedback