Left Menu
Development News Edition

CORRECTED-EXPLAINER-Is it illegal for Trump or Congress to name the impeachment whistleblower?


CORRECTED-EXPLAINER-Is it illegal for Trump or Congress to name the impeachment whistleblower?
US President Donald Trump (File photo) Image Credit: ANI

U.S. President Donald Trump and some Republican lawmakers are pushing for political and media allies to reveal the name of the whistleblower who prompted an impeachment inquiry. "The whistleblower should be revealed because the whistleblower gave false information," Trump told reporters on Sunday.

Rand Paul, a Republican senator from Kentucky, on Tuesday tweeted a link to an article from a right-wing news outlet that claims to have identified the whistleblower. On Wednesday, the president's son, Donald Trump Jr., tweeted a link to an article including the same name. Democrats, some Republicans, and members of the U.S. intelligence community have strongly objected to the effort, calling it everything from inappropriate to illegal.

Here is what U.S. law says about how whistleblowers in the intelligence community should file complaints, and the punishments for retaliation and identification.

WHAT STEPS DID THE WHISTLEBLOWER TAKE?

On Aug. 12, the whistleblower lodged a complaint with an internal government watchdog about a July 25 phone call between Trump and Ukraine's new president Volodymyr Zelenskiy. During that call, Trump pressed his Ukrainian counterpart to investigate a political rival, former Vice President Joe Biden, and his son Hunter Biden. The whistleblower filed the report with Intelligence Community Inspector General Michael Atkinson, as required under the Intelligence Community Whistleblower Protection Act of 1998, which lays out procedures for reporting allegations of fraud, waste, or violations of law.

Atkinson determined the complaint was credible and involved an urgent concern, and shared it with Acting Director of National Intelligence Joseph Maguire on Aug. 26, as required under the ICWPA. The ICWPA requires the director to report any complaint to Congressional intelligence committees within seven days. Maguire consulted with the White House, and the report was sent to prescribed members of Congress on Sept. 25.

Maguire found the complaint did not meet the legal definition of "urgent concern." But it has since prompted a House of Representatives investigation into whether Trump committed "high crimes and misdemeanors" warranting impeachment. John Cohen, a former official in the U.S. Department of Homeland Security, said the whistleblower followed the procedures laid out in the ICWPA, and that much of the whistleblower's complaint has been corroborated.

WHAT DOES U.S. LAW SAY ABOUT REVEALING A WHISTLEBLOWER'S NAME?

There is only one provision in the ICWPA that deals specifically with whistleblower anonymity, said Kel McClanahan, a national security lawyer in Washington.

That provision says the inspector general should not disclose the whistleblower's identity without their consent, unless the watchdog determines that "such disclosure is unavoidable during the course of the investigation." Once the complaint is out of the inspector general's hands the law does little to guarantee the whistleblower anonymity, said McClanahan, the executive director of National Security Counselors, a public interest law firm.

"It is presumed that people would want to not publicly expose a whistleblower because of all the public policy reasons for not doing so," said McClanahan. Members of the House Permanent Select Committee on Intelligence who reveal the whistleblower's identity could violate that committee's rules and face censure from fellow lawmakers, McClanahan said. Censure is largely symbolic, however, and does not remove a House member from office.

The whistleblower's lawyers said in a statement on Wednesday that efforts to identify their client "will place that individual and their family at risk of serious harm" and will deter future whistleblowers.

WHAT OTHER PROTECTIONS DOES U.S. LAW PROVIDE TO INTELLIGENCE COMMUNITY WHISTLEBLOWERS?

A 2012 directive from former President Barack Obama, formally put into law in 2014, supplemented the ICWPA to protect intelligence community whistleblowers from some forms of retaliation, including termination or security clearance revocation, if they follow rules for making disclosures. There are limits to the law's protections, however. Unlike other whistleblowers in the federal government, intelligence community whistleblowers are not permitted to file lawsuits over any perceived retaliation. Instead, they must pursue relief through an internal review process.

Notably, the 2014 law ultimately puts the president in charge of enforcing the whistleblower protections. Cohen, now a professor at Georgetown University, said the law was primarily intended to protect whistleblowers from workplace retaliation by colleagues and supervisors.

"It does not necessarily prevent disclosure of the identity of the whistleblower, which may subject the individual to retaliation from others," Cohen said.

WHAT SECURITY PROTECTIONS DOES THE U.S. FEDERAL GOVERNMENT PROVIDE A INTELLIGENCE COMMUNITY EMPLOYEE WHO IS TARGETED FOR WHISTLEBLOWING?

Obama's directive gave intelligence community whistleblowers some protections against workplace retaliation, but does not provide them with security guards or similar protections. House members have considered "extreme measures" to protect the whistleblower's identity in the event the individual testifies, including disguising their face and voice, CNN reported.

Lawyers for the whistleblower say they have received death threats after conservative media outlets have floated possible names.

IS THERE ARE ANY HISTORICAL PRECEDENT FOR THIS MOMENT?

Not really. Many government employees and contractors who have gone public with allegations of wrongdoing went directly to the press. "I do not think I have ever seen a president, his allies in Congress and even his family work this hard to publicly disclose the name of a whistleblower who has followed the law," said Cohen.

"Its disturbing - particularly in light of the fact that the concerns raised by the whistleblower have for the most part been validated by witnesses with first hand knowledge," Cohen said.

(This story has not been edited by Devdiscourse staff and is auto-generated from a syndicated feed.)


TRENDING

OPINION/BLOG/INTERVIEW

These innovators are making humanitarian response more efficient

These alarming trends prompt a call for the world to not only address the ongoing crisis but also to adopt innovative approaches to fulfill the growing humanitarian needs in such emergencies. ...

Hyderabad Encounter: A sentiment analysis of public mood on day of encounter

Sentiment analysis of twitter users revealed that they showered salutes on Hyderabad police for eliminating alleged gang rapists of the veterinary doctor but only a few believe in cops version of successive events leading to encounter....

Hyderabad Encounter: Time to review modern judiciary and restore people’s confidence

Its probably for the first time in the history of independent India, the parliamentarians, chief ministers and ministers in the Union and State governments are openly supporting an encounter. This indicates the people from top to bottom hav...

What happens to your outstanding loans if the bank falls?

... ...

Videos

Latest News

UPDATE 3-New Zealand volcano death toll rises to 8 and will continue to climb

The death toll from a New Zealand volcano eruption rose to eight on Thursday, with two victims dying in hospital, and will continue to climb with eight victims presumed dead on the island and more than 20 in intensive care suffering severe ...

GLOBAL MARKETS-Asian shares climb on dovish Fed, but Brexit hurdle looms

Asian stocks rose on Thursday to the highest in a month after the Federal Reserve signalled rate settings were likely to remain accommodative, but the imminent UK election and a deadline for Sino-U.S. trade talks kept investors cautious. Th...

Champions League: PSG thrash Galatasaray 5-0

Paris Saint Germain PSG on Thursday secured a massive 5-0 win over Galatasaray in Champions League. PSG had already qualified in the last 16 of the competition and finished on the top of Group A with 16 points.The club got off to an aggress...

James lifts Lakers past Magic with 6th triple-double

LeBron James collected 25 points, 11 rebounds and 10 assists for his sixth triple-double of the season as the visiting Los Angeles Lakers posted a 96-87 victory over the Orlando Magic on Wednesday. Reigning Western Conference Player of the ...

Give Feedback