Natural Riches, Ecological Risks: Why Regulation Changes the Equation for BRICS+
Natural resource wealth can finance economic expansion while placing enormous pressure on ecosystems, creating a persistent dilemma for countries dependent on oil, gas, minerals and other natural assets. Yet the environmental consequences of resource wealth are not predetermined. Research examining the expanded BRICS+ economies suggests that regulatory quality can change whether natural resource rents are associated with ecological deterioration or improved environmental conditions.
The study, titled "Natural Resource Rents and Ecological Footprint in BRICS+: The Moderating Role of Regulatory Quality," was authored by Temitayo Blessing Majekodunmi of the University of South Africa and published in the journal Economies in November 2026. Analyzing 11 BRICS+ economies between 2002 and 2021, it investigates how natural resource rents, regulatory quality, economic growth and renewable energy consumption relate to ecological footprint.
The findings challenge conventional assumptions about resource dependence. Natural resource rents are negatively associated with ecological footprint in the principal long-run model, while stronger regulatory quality reinforces this relationship. However, the association reverses under weaker regulatory conditions, suggesting that resource wealth may accompany greater environmental pressure where institutional effectiveness is limited. Economic growth, meanwhile, remains positively associated with ecological footprint.
Resource Wealth Does Not Follow a Single Environmental Path
Natural resources occupy a central position in the development strategies of several BRICS+ economies, supporting public revenues, industrial activity and infrastructure investment. Yet the extraction and consumption of these resources can intensify ecological pressure through pollution, land conversion, energy demand and environmental degradation. The relationship between resource wealth and sustainability has consequently generated conflicting findings across economic research.
Some studies associate natural resource rents with worsening environmental conditions, reflecting the ecological costs of extraction and resource-intensive production. Others identify favorable relationships, suggesting that resource-derived income can coexist with improved environmental outcomes. Majekodunmi's research examines whether regulatory quality helps explain these differences rather than treating resource abundance as inherently beneficial or environmentally damaging.
The analysis measures environmental pressure through ecological footprint, which captures demands on biologically productive land and marine areas associated with resource consumption and waste absorption. Its components include cropland, grazing land, forests, fishing grounds, built-up land and the carbon footprint. This broader measure allows the researcher to examine environmental pressure beyond carbon emissions alone.
The study covers Brazil, Russia, India, China, South Africa, Egypt, Ethiopia, Iran, Indonesia, Saudi Arabia and the United Arab Emirates. Although the expanded BRICS+ composition emerged after the observation period, the researcher applies the grouping retrospectively to construct a consistent historical dataset comprising 220 country-year observations.
Environmental information comes from the Global Footprint Network, while the World Bank supplies indicators covering natural resource rents, regulatory quality, GDP per capita and renewable energy consumption. The analysis uses statistical methods designed to account for differences among countries and their exposure to shared economic influences, with additional estimation techniques employed to examine the consistency of results.
The principal long-run model identifies a statistically significant negative relationship between natural resource rents and ecological footprint, with an estimated coefficient of −0.0133. Rather than indicating that resource extraction automatically benefits the environment, this finding establishes that higher resource rents are associated with lower ecological pressure within the estimated model.
The researcher suggests that resource revenues may contribute to cleaner production or environmental improvements. However, the analysis does not directly establish how those revenues were allocated or whether particular investments produced measurable environmental benefits.
Regulatory Quality Emerges as the Deciding Institutional Factor
The research examines how regulatory quality modifies the relationship between natural resource rents and ecological footprint. Rather than evaluating institutional effectiveness only as a separate environmental determinant, the study investigates whether regulatory conditions change the environmental association of resource-derived income.
The principal model identifies a negative and statistically significant interaction coefficient of −0.0311. This indicates that stronger regulatory quality is associated with a more favorable relationship between resource rents and ecological footprint, suggesting that institutional arrangements influence how resource wealth relates to environmental sustainability.
The relationship becomes clearer when regulatory conditions are examined separately. At the lowest regulatory-quality level assessed, natural resource rents have a positive and statistically significant marginal effect of 0.0223 on logged ecological footprint. Under these conditions, higher resource rents are associated with increasing ecological pressure rather than environmental improvement.
At the median regulatory-quality level, the estimated marginal effect falls to −0.0053 but is not statistically significant. At the highest regulatory-quality level, the relationship becomes significantly negative, reaching −0.0320. The contrast indicates that the association between natural resource rents and ecological pressure changes substantially across institutional environments.
The findings support the researcher's argument that regulatory effectiveness influences whether resource wealth becomes associated with environmentally favorable outcomes. Stronger institutional arrangements may support more accountable resource management, credible environmental policies and investment in sustainable activities, while weaker regulation may leave resource-intensive development accompanied by greater ecological pressure.
An important distinction emerges from the estimates. Regulatory quality does not show a statistically significant direct relationship with ecological footprint in the principal model. Its significance appears through interaction with natural resource rents, indicating that institutional effectiveness may shape environmental outcomes differently depending on the economic activity under consideration.
However, the evidence is not entirely uniform. Alternative estimation methods broadly support the negative relationship between resource rents and ecological footprint, but the regulatory interaction is statistically significant under one robustness method and insignificant under another. The direction remains consistent, although the strength of statistical support varies across techniques.
Economic Expansion Continues to Carry an Ecological Cost
The potentially favorable relationship between resource rents and ecological footprint does not extend automatically to wider economic growth. The principal model identifies a positive and statistically significant association between GDP per capita and ecological footprint, with a coefficient of 0.3335, indicating that expanding economic activity remains linked to greater environmental pressure.
This result reflects the continuing tension between economic development and the demand placed on ecosystems. Greater production, consumption and resource use can increase ecological pressure even where resource revenues are associated with more favorable environmental outcomes. The evidence therefore distinguishes the relationship involving resource rents from the broader consequences of economic expansion.
Country-specific estimates reveal considerable variation. Economic growth is positively associated with ecological footprint in China, Ethiopia, India, Russia and South Africa. Brazil and Iran display negative relationships, indicating that the growth-environment connection differs across the economies examined rather than following a single regional pattern.
Natural resource rents also produce contrasting national results. China records a statistically significant positive association between resource rents and ecological footprint, while India exhibits a significant negative relationship. The interaction between resource rents and regulatory quality is significantly negative in China, suggesting that stronger regulation may moderate its unfavorable resource-related environmental association.
Renewable energy consumption introduces another distinction. Although its coefficient is negative in the principal long-run model, the relationship is not statistically significant. The analysis therefore does not establish that renewable energy consumption consistently reduces ecological footprint across the entire BRICS+ sample over the period examined.
The country-level findings are more differentiated. Renewable energy consumption is significantly associated with lower ecological footprint in Brazil, China, Ethiopia, Indonesia and the United Arab Emirates. Iran records a positive relationship, which the researcher discusses in connection with the possibility that renewable energy may supplement conventional energy consumption rather than replace it.
These differences demonstrate why regional averages require careful interpretation. Countries within BRICS+ vary considerably in resource dependence, regulatory conditions, economic structures and energy consumption patterns. Their environmental relationships consequently cannot be reduced to uniform assumptions about development, renewable energy adoption or institutional strength.
From Resource Extraction to Environmental Governance
The research places regulatory governance at the center of resource-related environmental policy. Its findings suggest that governments seeking to reconcile natural resource income with sustainability should consider institutional effectiveness, transparency and accountability alongside extraction policies and industrial development strategies.
For BRICS+ policymakers, the study recommends strengthening environmental governance and improving the management of resource-generated revenues. More effective regulatory frameworks may help create conditions under which resource wealth is associated with reduced ecological pressure, although the estimates do not establish that regulatory reforms alone will produce such outcomes.
The positive association between economic growth and ecological footprint creates an additional policy challenge. The researcher recommends cleaner production technologies, greater resource efficiency and low-carbon development strategies to address environmental pressures associated with expanding economic activity. Renewable energy investment also remains a priority despite the absence of a statistically significant long-run relationship across the full sample.
The analysis contributes to debates over the natural resource curse by challenging the idea that resource abundance inevitably leads to unfavorable environmental outcomes. Its institutional focus suggests that resource wealth and environmental sustainability should be examined together with the governance structures within which economic activities take place.
Nevertheless, the study's limitations restrict definitive policy conclusions. Ecological footprint does not capture every dimension of environmental sustainability, including biodiversity loss and certain forms of ecosystem degradation. The model also excludes potentially influential factors such as urbanization, technological innovation, trade openness, industrial structure and financial development.
The researcher acknowledges that unobserved structural changes and reverse causality cannot be entirely excluded. Future investigations could examine oil, gas and mineral rents separately, incorporate alternative environmental indicators and use different methods to clarify causal relationships. Longer observation periods and broader comparisons could further assess the durability of the reported associations.
For resource-rich developing economies, the findings identify a governance challenge extending beyond the availability of natural wealth. Economic growth remains associated with ecological pressure, while the environmental relationship involving resource rents varies considerably with institutional conditions. The research thus offers a more qualified understanding of resource-led development: natural wealth is neither an automatic environmental liability nor a guaranteed route to sustainability, and the quality of regulatory institutions is closely associated with which outcome becomes more likely.
- FIRST PUBLISHED IN:
- Devdiscourse
Google News