Left Menu
Development News Edition

Info on extension of LS Secretary General's tenure not exempted under RTI, says HC

PTI | New Delhi | Updated: 03-07-2019 18:44 IST | Created: 03-07-2019 18:36 IST
Info on extension of LS Secretary General's tenure not exempted under RTI, says HC
"I also hold that in this case the petitioner's statutory right to information must trump the plea of parliamentary privilege since the latter must be construed so as to confine it to cases where it is necessary for preserving and protecting legislative function,"

The Delhi High Court has held that information on the extension of tenure of Secretary General of Lok Sabha is not exempted from disclosure under the RTI Act as it is granted by the Speaker, head of the administrative wing of the House. The court said parliamentary privilege is not a "catch-all phrase" to claim blanket protection from disclosure of information that is connected with a legislative body.

Justice A J Bhambhani directed the Lok Sabha Secretariat to give the information to RTI activist Subhash Chandra Agarwal on queries relating to the extension of tenure of the then Secretary General of the Lok Sabha in 2011. The information was earlier denied to the RTI applicant on the ground that it would amount to 'breach of privilege' of Parliament and the information was exempted under section 8(1)(c) of the Right to Information Act.

He had sought complete and detailed information with related correspondence or file-notings on action taken on letter of then Leader of Opposition Sushma Swaraj written to the then Speaker of Lok Sabha Meira Kumar against granting an extension of one year to Secretary General of the House T K Vishwanathan. The information was denied by the Central Public Information Officer of Lok Sabha Secretariat on the ground that communications and consultation by the Speaker with functionaries of the House, in this case, the Leader of Opposition, in the discharge of constitutional duties may cause a breach of parliamentary privilege.

The Central Information Commission (CIC) had also dismissed Agarwal's appeal and upheld the CPIO's order against which he appealed in the high court. Justice Bhambhani, however, said, "In the circumstances, I am of the view that information in relation to consultation and communications that went on between the Leader of the Opposition, the Leader of the House and the Speaker in relation to the extension of the Secretary General's term enjoys no exemption from disclosure, much less on the ground of parliamentary privilege; and ought to have been disclosed."

The high court said the extension of Secretary-General's tenure was granted by the Speaker as the head of the administrative wing of the House and not by any collective or collegiate action or decision on the part of the House or any committee of the House. It said the matter of extension of tenure was not debated or discussed by the House since it was not part of the legislative function or any other parliamentary function of the House or any committee of the House and this communication between the functionaries did not pertain to their role in any proceedings in Parliament.

"Disclosure of such consultation and communications would not, by any stretch of imagination or reasoning, hinder, impede or interfere with the participation of the Leader of the Opposition, Leader of the House and/or the Speaker in any proceedings of the House; and did not have the potential to distort, obstruct or threaten the integrity of the legislative process in any manner. The disclosure would not be prejudicial to the core legislative function of the House," it said. The high court set aside the order of the CIC saying the CIC committed an error in not deciding whether the information sought by the petitioner falls within the exemption under section 8(1)(c) of the RTI Act and instead of leaving that issue to be decided by the Speaker.

Lok Sabha Secretariat was represented through advocate Rajshekhar Rao. The court said once it has come to the conclusion that the information sought has nothing to do with proceedings in Parliament and is therefore not covered by the very concept of parliamentary privilege, the question of the exemption under section 8(1)(c) applying to such information does not arise.

"I also hold that in this case the petitioner's statutory right to information must trump the plea of parliamentary privilege since the latter must be construed so as to confine it to cases where it is necessary for preserving and protecting legislative function," the judge said. The court said that the information sought by the petitioner be furnished to him within four weeks and if the information has already been weeded-out in compliance with the rules for weeding-out or destruction of records of Parliament, an affidavit of the appropriate officer be filed in the court.


TRENDING

OPINION / BLOG / INTERVIEW

3D printing and the future of manufacturing post COVID-19

The on-demand, customizable, and localized manufacturing of product components facilitated by 3D printing has the potential to redefine manufacturing but there are certain technical, mechanical, and legal limitations that, unless ...

How UK’s 'best prepared' healthcare system failed to gauge COVID-19

The UK is proud of their public health system and its unlike any other country as around 90 percent of British public supports the founding principles of National Health Service. But without accurate data being available to stakeholders in ...

Poor on IHR capacity progress in 2019, WHO says Cambodia tops COVID-19 response

Despite being in proximity to Hubei, the original epicenter of COVID-19 pandemic, Cambodia has reported just 226 confirmed cases and zero deaths. After seeing the data, WHO appreciated Cambodias healthcare information system but experts dou...

Loopholes in Healthcare Information System may have failed Singapore COVID-19 model

In the initial days of the COVID-19 outbreak, Singapore was in the limelight for its effective healthcare system and pandemic response plan. However, Singapore has now joined the list of the worst-hit nations and the situation is even worse...

Videos

Latest News

Mahesh Bhatt's 'Sadak 2' to premiere on Disney+ Hotstar on August 28

Mumbai, Aug 6 PTI Alia Bhatt and Aditya Roy Kapoors Sadak 2 will be released on August 28 on Disney Hotstar. Alia shared the news on her official Instagram page as she shared a new poster of the much-awaited movie. Sadak 2, the road to love...

Cargill invests USD 15 mn to set up plant for cattle supplements in Maharashtra

US food major Cargill on Thursday said it has invested USD 15 million around Rs 112 crore to set up a plant in Maharashtra to manufacture health and nutrition supplement bypass fat for dairy cattle. Cargill India, which posted a revenue of ...

COVID-19: Eight people die in Rajasthan, 539 new cases

Rajasthan reported eight deaths due to COVID-19 and 539 new cases of the virus on Thursday, officials said. The deaths were reported from Bikaner 5, Dholpur 2 and Jodhpur 1, taking the total number of fatalities in the state to 753.The numb...

Inflation likely to be elevated in second quarter: RBI Governor

The Reserve Bank of India RBI on Thursday said inflation is expected to be at elevated levels during the second quarter, but may ease in the second half of the current fiscal year. Supply chain disruptions persist, resulting in inflation pr...

Give Feedback