Green Investment Gap in India: How Values, Peer Influence and Financial Knowledge Mix

Researchers compared new batteries with repurposed electric vehicle batteries used to store electricity during cheaper hours and sell it when prices rise. Their analysis explored how aging, downtime, maintenance and the practical difficulties of collecting and preparing used batteries change the financial picture.

Green Investment Gap in India: How Values, Peer Influence and Financial Knowledge Mix
Representative image Image Credit: ChatGPT

Caring about the environment can influence everyday choices, from reducing waste to choosing cleaner transport, but investing savings brings a different set of questions. People considering green shares need to weigh environmental promises against financial risks, unfamiliar information and the possibility that a company's claims are exaggerated. A study of retail investors in Mumbai and Navi Mumbai explores what shapes their willingness to make that choice.

Researchers Deepti Menon and Razia Nagina examine these questions in "Nudging Sustainable Investments: The Role of Environmental Concern, Financial Literacy and SEBI Saarthi 2.0 in Green Shares Intention," published in the Journal of Risk and Financial Management. Their research brings together environmental values, social expectations, financial knowledge and a regulator's investor education app. The findings suggest that concern for the planet and encouragement from others have clearer positive links with green investment intentions than access to information alone.

The research speaks to the challenge of attracting household savings into investments that support a cleaner economy. Its focus is people's stated willingness to buy green shares, so the results cannot establish whether those intentions became purchases. That distinction matters when interpreting both the findings and the authors' suggestions for encouraging participation.

A Snapshot of Young Investors and Their Information Sources

The researchers analysed 325 valid responses from a 41-item questionnaire completed by retail investors in Mumbai and Navi Mumbai. Nearly 75% of participants were under 25, about 57% were male, and 71% had less than a year of investment experience. This makes the study especially useful for understanding younger beginners, with less scope for drawing conclusions about experienced investors or India's wider population.

Friends and family were the main investment information source for almost 51% of respondents, followed by social media and influencers at around 18%. Financial news and journals accounted for roughly 15%, professional advisers for 11%, and SEBI Saarthi app or portal resources for under 5%. Around 25% reported owning green or ESG investments, 60% reported none, and 15% were unsure, revealing uncertainty about products associated with environmental, social and governance standards.

The analysis extended the Theory of Planned Behaviour, which connects intentions with personal attitudes, social expectations and people's sense of control over their actions. Financial literacy, environmental concern and SEBI Saarthi 2.0 were added to examine how these factors work together, using a modelling method called PLS-SEM. The model explained 40% of the differences in investment intentions, leaving considerable room for influences outside the study.

Environmental Values and Social Circles Carry Weight

Environmental concern showed one of the clearest positive relationships with willingness to invest in green shares. People who felt greater concern for the environment were more inclined towards these investments, and that concern strengthened the connection between favourable attitudes and investment intentions. A positive opinion of green investing carried more weight among participants who cared deeply about environmental issues.

Social expectations from family, friends and professional networks showed another clear positive relationship with investment intentions. This finding fits a sample in which personal connections were the leading source of investment information. The researchers suggest that investment firms could use credible examples of participation and messages tailored to particular investor groups to make sustainable investing more relatable.

A favourable attitude by itself produced a borderline result that did not meet the study's chosen evidence threshold. Feeling more capable of making investment decisions had a small negative relationship with green investment intentions, running against the researchers' prediction. The authors suggest that overconfidence or the perceived burden of evaluating ESG information could help explain this pattern, but those explanations were not directly established.

Financial Knowledge Can Bring More Caution

The study separated people's confidence in their financial understanding from their knowledge measured through factual questions. Greater factual knowledge was associated with lower green investment intentions, with a small effect size. The authors interpret this as possible caution about greenwashing and incomplete company disclosures, rather than evidence that financial education undermines environmental values.

Confidence in financial knowledge showed no clear direct relationship with investment intentions. Neither measured knowledge nor self-rated financial understanding clearly changed the relationship between favourable attitudes and willingness to invest. These results suggest that knowing more, feeling knowledgeable and wanting to buy green shares are separate parts of the decision.

SEBI Saarthi 2.0 showed no clear direct relationship with green investment intentions and did not strengthen the connection between perceived control and willingness to invest. About 43% answered yes to a combined question about awareness or use of the app, which does not establish how many were regular users. The authors describe its role in this sample as an educational resource, with limited evidence that it actively encouraged green investment decisions.

Clearer Information and Better Tools Need Testing

The paper recommends simpler green labels and consumer-friendly ESG scorecards to help people assess investment products. Education focused on greenwashing, sustainability claims and long-term returns considered alongside risk could address questions that general financial lessons leave unanswered. Interactive risk assessments, carbon-impact dashboards and tools for recording investment commitments are proposed as ways to make regulatory platforms more useful.

A proposed "Green Loyalty Framework" would introduce rewards such as green credits or fee-discount badges for purchasing certified sustainable assets. The idea draws on the satisfaction people may feel when their financial choices support environmental values. This framework was not tested in the study, so its ability to change investment behaviour remains an open question.

The survey captured one point in time within two urban financial centres, and its young, inexperienced sample limits how widely the findings can be applied. Limited app adoption adds another constraint, making studies across different regions, longer-term tracking and experiments with actual purchases useful next steps. Environmental motivation and social encouragement deserve attention, supported by clearer information that helps investors judge whether green claims are credible.

  • FIRST PUBLISHED IN:
  • Devdiscourse
Give Feedback

Use this form for editorial or site feedback. We usually reply within 2 to 3 working days.

By submitting, you agree that we may use your email address to respond.