Left Menu
Development News Edition

Germany's economic identity faces questions as Thyssenkrupp undergoes disturbance

Devdiscourse News Desk | Updated: 17-05-2019 16:45 IST | Created: 17-05-2019 16:33 IST
Germany's economic identity faces questions as Thyssenkrupp undergoes disturbance
Thyssenkrupp's conglomerate structure has fallen out of favour in the market, reflected in the deterioration of its share price. Image Credit: Wikimedia Commons

When Thyssenkrupp CEO Guido Kerkhoff announced plans to list its prized elevators unit last week, he set off a battle for the conglomerate's future that could test Germany's brand of "social market" capitalism.

Kerkhoff had little choice but to think the unthinkable when the company's share price sank to a 15-year low on May 8. The plan to take elevators public not only broke with a long tradition but marked the abandonment of a turnaround plan he himself had unveiled less than eight months before. Now Thyssenkrupp's future is in play, with activist investors on the one side baying for a restructuring of the group to drive up value, and its top shareholder - the charitable Krupp foundation - and workers on the other side with a mandate to protect the unity of the company and jobs.

It's also a clash of cultures and of differing visions of capitalism: Anglo-Saxon profit maximisation pitted against Germany's long-term focused social market economy model. Kerkhoff's strategy will not only decide the fate of his career, but also the shape of Thyssenkrupp - a poster child of Germany's so-called Rhineland capitalism, which buttressed the country's economic success by emphasising social policies to protect workers rights as much as the rules of free enterprise.

Thyssenkrupp's conglomerate structure has fallen out of favour in the market, reflected in the deterioration of its share price. Many investors say Kerkhoff and the non-profit foundation must move to reshape the group's portfolio, including through spin-offs and divestments. Ingo Speich, head of sustainability and corporate governance at top-20 shareholder Deka Investment, said this kind of active portfolio management was the likeliest and the best solution for the group.

"Parts will be separated out and the resulting proceeds used to make acquisitions." Bankers and investors are now eyeing the prospect of finding new owners for the group's sprawling businesses, ranging from steel and elevators to car parts and submarines.

Components Technology, which makes automotive parts, and Industrial Solutions, which makes chemical and cement plants, may be merged with sector peers in the medium to long-term, according to three financial sources familiar with the matter. Elevators may end up in the hands of Kone or Schindler, should they intercept Thyssenkrupp's IPO plans, while plant engineering could be combined with Linde's engineering unit, one of the sources said.

Other investment bank pitches to potential buyers will focus on finding a partner for some of Thyssenkrupp's automotive businesses, where Bosch, ZF Friedrichshafen, Nexteer or Mando are seen as potential players, according to the sources. The company's Rothe Erde machine parts unit may attract interest from Sweden's SKF, Schaeffler and Japan's NSK, they said.

"This is the breakup of Thyssenkrupp," said a senior banker who declined to be named due to the sensitivity of the matter. All the companies either declined to comment on potential deals or were not immediately available to comment.

Kerkhoff has acknowledged that new ownership structures for its businesses is needed to turn the company around. But ThyssenKrupp declined to comment on any future asset sales.


Such a process will, however, be lengthy and difficult, according to three separate financial and labour sources, for two reasons: apart from elevators, all other units of ThyssenKrupp are less profitable than their peer average, are going through a restructuring or are in need of one. This is reducing their value and makes it less probable that an M&A frenzy will ensue.

"I don't see quick, easy wins unless assets are sold under value," said another senior banker. "A fire sale is not the way forward." Secondly, powerful labour representatives at ThyssenKrupp, who control half of the seats on group's 20-member supervisory board, are willing to oppose M&A that will result in further job cuts among its 161,000-strong workforce.

The 10 workers' representatives can team up with the Alfried Krupp von Bohlen and Halbach Foundation, which holds a 21 per cent stake, to veto major changes. The foundation's mandate is to preserve the unity of the company while at the same time relying on healthy dividends to fund its non-profit activities for promoting the "common good".

It, therefore, needs to tread carefully, preserving the company's future without obstructing needed reforms. The elevator IPO, part of a plan that also includes 6,000 job reductions, has found support because it brings in cash that is badly needed to fix Thyssenkrupp's balance sheet and strengthen the businesses as a whole.

"It will be a difficult path for the company and its employees. But we won't abandon workers," said Markus Grolms, vice chairman of ThyssenKrupp's supervisory board and secretary at IG Metall, Germany's biggest labour union.


The conflict at ThyssenKrupp also illustrates the growing influence of activist shareholders on European household names, with demands to tackle underperformance and simplify structures. Swedish investor Cevian, a shareholder since 2013 that has long pressed for change, holds an 18 per cent stake, while more recent investor Elliott holds under 3 per cent. Both have criticised Thyssenkrupp's underperformance.

Activists argue specialised businesses are often more highly valued than conglomerates because, in times of growth, high-potential assets do not have to share the balance sheet with cash-consuming, lower-return businesses. Conglomerates tend to be valued at a trading multiple of some of their lowest-performing business resulting in the so-called conglomerate discount and higher refinancing costs.

In recent years, groups that have reshaped their portfolios through spin-offs and sales have outperformed peers in terms of share price development, Goldman Sachs said in a study last year, a trend which helped asset disposals in Europe reach their highest level since 2007. "It's not necessarily that boards and companies were doing things wrong before," said Rich Thomas, managing director and head of European shareholder advisory at investment bank Lazard.

"But things are different now and now boards and companies need to do things differently because the world has moved a bit underneath them," he added, referring to the rise of investor activism. "And now, I think, in many ways, European and German boards are playing a little bit of catch-up." German labour leaders and credit agencies, for their part, argue a diversified model with exposure to several businesses with different growth, margin and cash flow generation rates is an advantage when one sector enters a downturn.


Germany has been slow to embrace portfolio management because of reforms introduced after World War II to safeguard worker rights.

In 1947, the United States forced the breakup of German industrial monopolies so that they could not be used as instruments of power by political forces, as had happened with the steel industry under the Nazis. Krupp, which later merged with Thyssen in 1999, was among the first companies to be dismantled. Among others, IG Farben was split into businesses including BASF, Hoechst and Bayer.

At the time, price controls were also lifted, sparking concerns among German workers about their welfare so Germany's leaders allowed industry associations including the German Trade Union Confederation and Federation of German Industries to help formulate new labour laws and working conditions. In 1949, collective wage-bargaining negotiations set a minimum wage for entire sectors to ensure competition would not mean a race to the bottom for wages. The law is still in place.

Three years later, trade unions were also given the right to appoint a third of company directors so they could have a say in determining the conditions of hiring and laying off workers when restructuring was needed. It is this law which has given Thyssenkrupp's workers a near veto power to stop radical job cuts and even to block the appointment of shareholder-friendly candidates to the board.

Decisions at ThyssenKrupp have rarely, if ever, been taken without the consent of workers. For CEO Kerkhoff, a deal for the elevator unit may mark one of the last chances to raise cash to pay for necessary reforms following three profit warnings, a botched plan to spin off its capital goods business and the collapse of a steel joint venture with Tata Steel.

But analysts at Jefferies are still sceptical about management's ability to get the listing off the ground. "The timeline and execution of such a deal remain concerns of investors," they said, adding management must come up with a credible restructuring plan that is supported by unions and convince markets the IPO will repair the group's balance sheet.



Domestic seafood trade in focus as COVID-19 changes market dynamics

As predicted earlier in a report titled Seafood industry post-COVID 19 An overhaul to trigger the growth of small fisheries, one of the changes going ahead would be increased focus on domestic seafood trade, driven by falling exports and su...

Migration post-COVID 19: Taking cues from the past to rebuild economies

Migrants are an irreplaceable part of even the essential workforce of developed countries and are on the frontline in the fight against the crisis, making an immeasurable contribution to saving the lives of natives with voting rights....

Socialization Post-COVID-19: Local associations and online groups to play crucial role

Though every age group is suffering due to the global lockdown caused by the ensuing COVID-19 pandemic, the challenges before adolescents are unique. Their social space has shrunk drastically, besides, they have become highly vulnerable to ...

Pharma post-COVID 19: Reducing political clout can alter business models

Powerful governments that have historically supported the pharma industry in enforcing global intellectual property rules are changing course and introducing legislation that can override normal patent rights during emergencies....


Latest News

Thailand reports 2 new coronavirus cases, 1 more death

Thailand confirmed two new coronavirus cases and one additional death on Monday, a health ministry spokesman said.The new numbers brought the total number of cases in the Southeast Asian country to 3,042 and deaths to 57 since the outbreak ...

Rain wipes out Florida women's exhibition event

The final day of a womens exhibition tournament in Florida featuring several WTA players was washed out by rainstorms, organizers announced. Its disappointing, but overall the team at UTR are so excited to bring back tennis and live sports ...

Home Minister Amit Shah extends Eid greetings

Union Home Minister Amit Shah on Monday extended his greetings on the occasion of Eid-ul-Fitr and wished that the festival will bring peace and happiness to allExtend my warm greetings on the occasion of Eid-ul-Fitr. May this festival bring...

Cricket-Saliva ban would be temporary, says ICC's Kumble

A recommendation banning the use of saliva to shine a cricket ball when the sport resumes after the novel coronavirus shutdown is only a temporary measure, Anil Kumble, the chairman of the International Cricket Councils Cricket Committee, h...

Give Feedback