Left Menu
Development News Edition

ANALYSIS-How Indian state's three-capital plan could spur equal growth

ANALYSIS-How Indian state's three-capital plan could spur equal growth
Image Credit: ANI

A proposal by the southern Indian state of Andhra Pradesh to have three capitals rather than one could be a model for more equal development and help release pressure from the country's overcrowded cities, say planning experts.

Last month, the government of Andhra Pradesh passed the Decentralisation and Equal Development of All Regions Bill to pave the way for three cities to be the executive, judicial and legislative centers, rather than build a new capital city. Having three capitals is an anomaly in India, where state capitals have long been centers of power, drawing the bulk of investment and infrastructure building, and becoming magnets for thousands of migrants from the villages every day seeking jobs.

But with increasingly crowded cities and lopsided economic growth in many states, decentralization is desperately needed, said Bhanu Joshi, a former member of a committee that studied the feasibility of the multi-capital plan. "Indian states focus on putting all their capital into just one big city instead of giving a boost to decentralized development, where more cities are adequately empowered and sustained to allow for balanced development," he said.

"Andhra Pradesh is endowed with different types of natural resources - a policy of balanced regional development is the only way forward," Joshi, a political scientist, told the Thomson Reuters Foundation. Andhra Pradesh was split in two in 2014 after a decades-long movement for a separate state, with Telangana, hived off the northwestern part in June 2014.

Andhra Pradesh's capital, Hyderabad, became the capital of Telangana, but will also remain capital of Andhra Pradesh for a period of up to 10 years so the state can establish its own capital. Andhra Pradesh's former chief minister N. Chandrababu Naidu, who is credited with transforming Hyderabad into a thriving technology hub, decided to build a new capital, Amaravati, touted as a "smart city" with environment-friendly features.

But the plan was beset by protests of farmers unwilling to give up land, and warnings of the ecological impact and potential for flooding from building close to the river. A new government led by Chief Minister Y.S. Jagan Mohan Reddy, who took office last May, commissioned studies into the feasibility of a multi-capital plan, then scrapped the Amaravati project based on their recommendations.

Amaravati - where some administrative buildings have been built - is to be the state's legislative capital, with the coastal city of Visakhapatnam becoming the executive capital and Kurnool the judicial capital, Reddy said. "We do not want to develop one area utilizing all our available financial resources while other areas suffer due to lack of funds," he told reporters.


Several countries, from Brazil to Myanmar, have tried to decongest their crowded capitals by moving or building new ones, but with mixed success.

Bolivia, Chile, Malaysia and the Netherlands are among countries with two capitals each, while South Africa - cited by Reddy as a model - has long had three capitals. In India, some states had summer and winter capitals during the British colonial era.

A few states, in recent decades, have invested in developing smaller cities as manufacturing, academic or tourism hubs to create jobs and address sharp regional imbalances. India has five megacities with populations of more than 10 million each and is forecast to have two more by 2030, according to the United Nations.

Each of these cities - including Mumbai, Delhi and Kolkata - suffers from lack of adequate public transport and affordable housing, along with increasing congestion and pollution. While big cities create wealth and generate employment, they also drive climate change impacts, and worsen inequality and exclusion, said the U.N.

But simply declaring a city a capital will not guarantee decentralization or more equal development, said Srinivas Chokkakula, a fellow at the Centre for Policy Research, a think tank in New Delhi. "The idea of decentralized growth needs to be institutionalized and there need to be deliberate efforts to ensure investments," he said.

Authorities will face infrastructure challenges and environmental risks including climate change in each of the three cities, and will need to build efficient linkages between them, he said. "Calling a city a capital may bring some attention and some investments, but the challenge will be sustaining it for a more balanced, equitable growth and development," he said.


The state is setting up regional economic development boards that will ensure the benefits of economic growth are accessible to everyone, authorities have said.

But farmers in more than two dozen villages who pooled at least 33,000 acres (13,355 hectares) of land for the new capital in Amaravati have protested for weeks against the decision to abandon the project, which authorities had said would be a financial boon for landowners. A wider public consultation process would have helped make the decision more acceptable, said E.A.S. Sarma, a land rights activist and a former bureaucrat who had filed a petition against the Amaravati project.

What's now required is proper planning, or moving the heads of departments and the secretariat to Visakhapatnam will "impose severe stress on the resources of the city" including water, housing, and land, he said. "It will only create new problems for the residents."

(This story has not been edited by Devdiscourse staff and is auto-generated from a syndicated feed.)

Download The Devdiscourse News App for Latest News.



Coronavirus lockdowns to speed up long-pending change in supply chains

With millions of production lines impacted, business disruptions to some extent are unavoidable and the lessons learned from this turbulence will leave an everlasting impact on both global and local levels of supply chains....

COVID 19 to catalyze the redefinition of urban planning and sustainability

Until now the urban planning was focused on mitigation to natural disastrous, climate change, pollution, chronic illness and lifestyle diseases. However, the global pandemic of novel coronavirus is going to change the whole narrative of urb...

Ebola to COVID 19: Has Geopolitics prevailed over Professionalism in WHO

World Health Organization WHO is perceived as one of the most professional bodies of the United Nations. However, the role of WHO has come under question in handling outbreak two deadly diseases Ebola Viral Disease EVD and novel Coronaviru...

Trade War, COVID 19 and Beyond: How Pandemic is defining a New World Order

While we are confined in our homes, the world is changing faster than ever. Geopolitics in the time pandemic is defining a new world order. The transformation is happening in almost all the walks of life but the million-dollar question is ...


Latest News

Sisodia visits Delhi govt school to inspect newly-converted shelter homes for poor

Delhi Deputy Chief Minister Manish Sisodia on Saturday paid a visit to Sarvodaya Co-Ed Senior Secondary School in IP Extension here, to inspect the newly converted shelter homes for the poor, who are facing the brunt due to lockdown imposed...

Karnataka Deputy CM warns those defying lockdown orders

Karnataka Deputy Chief Minister Govind Karjol on Ssturday said the coronavirus epidemic has reached the third phase and cautioned people defying the lockdown orders. Today the coronavirus epidemic has entered the third phase. By and large p...

Goa villages seal borders amid COVID-19 lockdown

From sealing their village borders to feeding stray dogs, Goans have joined hands to make the 21-day lockdown a success in the coastal state. Goa has detected three COVID-19 cases so far and the state started its own testing facility at Goa...

Ludhiana faces medicine shortage as wholesale supply stops

Drug shortage in medical stores across Ludhiana as medical store owners in the city say that their stock of medicine is almost exhausted due to the closure of wholesale markets. The people are coming to the medicine shops in huge numbers. D...

Give Feedback