Left Menu
Development News Edition

HC rejects challenge to TN election rule on draw of lots to


HC rejects challenge to TN election rule on draw of lots to

The Madras High Court on Friday dismissed a PIL challenging a Tamil Nadu Panchayats election

rule which provided for draw of lots to decide the winner in case of a tie on vote count in polls, holding it cannot be

considered anti-democratic or purely fortuitous or casual. Noting that the voter's interest being equally divided

also amounted to reposing equal confidence in both candidates, a bench of Chief Justice A P Sahi and Justice Subramonium

Prasad said it therefore cannot be said that one was inferior or superior to the other.

To us, it appears the legislature was conscious of such situations and, therefore, in order to provide a workable and

operational system and to avoid further uncertainty by prolonging the process through fresh elections, thought it

appropriate to provide an additional vote amongst those who had secured equal number of votes by the draw of a lot," it

said. The bench was passing a detailed order on a the public

interest litigation petition filed by K Devadass of Adaiyur in Tiruvannamalai district whose rival M Kalaivani was

declared winner in the village panchayat poll by draw of lots after both secured same number of votes.

The petitioner sought to declare Rule 67(1)(c) of the Tamil Nadu Panchayats (Elections) Rules, 1995, which provide

for the tie-break, as invalid and utral vires. The bench rejected arguments and suggestions of the

petitioner's counsel that there can be a fresh election or the two may be allowed to work on a 50:50 tenure basis or provide

a second opportunity to those who did not exercise their franchise on the polling day.

All this is in the realm of the wisdom of the legislature to formulate a method so as to make it workable...

The very nature of a singular office, therefore, necessitates the existence of a method in order to terminate the

proceedings and allow the system to function," it said. The court said it found no merit in the contention that

the rule was ultra vires either to the provisions of the act or to the democratic principles of the holding of an election

by exercise of right of franchise or even violative of Article 14 of the Constitution.

On the question of an alternative method, the bench said it was for the legislature to decide.

(This story has not been edited by Devdiscourse staff and is auto-generated from a syndicated feed.)

Download The Devdiscourse News App for Latest News.


TRENDING

OPINION/BLOG/INTERVIEW

Top 10 Fake News, Myths and Realities on 2019 Novel Coronavirus COVID 19

With nearly 1500 deaths by January 14 and around 65,000 infections in China, the Novel Coronavirus 2019 has become one of the worst health epidemics of the 21st Century. However, 8,573 people have been cured but the rumor mongers are a...

Handling fake news Infodemic in time of Coronavirus epidemic

Social media has provided a platform where everybody can disseminate his her views without any supervision. Its excellent if the message is genuine but misinformation is equally disastrous. Health is such a topic where every Tom and Harry c...

Sentiment Analysis on Budget 2020: Long shot for solution to economic worries?

Industries and individuals alike had high expectations from the government to take tangible steps but the budget 2020 seems to have failed expectations....

How can technology help the future of mobility?

More than a billion people or one-third of the global rural population lacked access to all-season roads and transport services in 2016, subsequently hindering the socio-economic development....

Videos

Latest News

UPDATE 2-Weinstein rape trial deliberations resume after defense tries to oust juror

The jury in former Hollywood producer Harvey Weinsteins rape trial resumed deliberations on Wednesday, as his lawyers failed in their effort to get a juror removed for writing a review of a novel partly set in the MeToo era during the trial...

Redskins bringing back RB Adrian Peterson

Adrian Peterson will return to the Washington Redskins in 2020 as the team officially picked up his option for next season. Adrian Peterson is the epitome of what it means to be a pro in this league, new coach Ron Rivera said. Adrians leade...

UPDATE 3-Britain has long known EU free trade deal needs fair competition - EU adviser

The European Union flagged to Britain long before it left the bloc that any future free trade deal would have to come with a commitment from London to uphold fair competition, a senior EU adviser said on Wednesday. Britain left the EU in Ja...

Passenger tries to forcibly open aircraft door, 5 deplaned for unruly behaviour

A group of five people were off-loaded from IndiGos Delhi-Jeddah flight on Tuesday for unruly behaviour with one of them trying to forcibly open a door of the aircraft as it was taxiing for takeoff, insisting that their two companions who l...

Give Feedback