Left Menu
Development News Edition

Federal judge hears final round of arguments in Harvard bias case


Federal judge hears final round of arguments in Harvard bias case

A federal judge weighing whether Harvard University discriminates against Asian-American applicants said on Wednesday both the Ivy League school and a non-profit suing it faced potential problems in proving their positions. U.S. District Judge Allison Burroughs in Boston gave the assessment while hearing a final round of arguments in the case, whose outcome could have implications for other U.S. colleges that consider race as a factor when selecting students.

Burroughs asked why Students for Fair Admissions (SFFA), which was founded by anti-affirmative action activist Edward Blum, called no students during a trial that ended in November who could claim Harvard rejected them because of their race. She also asked Harvard's lawyers what she should make of statistics SFFA presented showing Asian-Americans received a "penalty" compared with other groups on a subjective "personal" rating measuring an applicant's likability and grit. "They have the victim problem, but you guys have that personal rating," Burroughs said.

Legal experts have said the case has the potential to reach the U.S. Supreme Court, giving the newly cemented five-member conservative majority a chance to bar the use of affirmative action to help minority applicants get into college. In previous rulings on affirmative action, which aims to offset historic patterns of racial discrimination, the Supreme Court has allowed colleges to include race as one factor among others in assessing applicants.

SFFA alleges Harvard went further than allowed by engaging in "racial balancing" and keeping Asian-American admissions in the years before SFFA sued in 2014 at or under 20 percent annually. The U.S. Justice Department under Republican President Donald Trump has backed SFFA's case, saying Harvard has not seriously considered race-neutral approaches to admissions. It has also opened a related investigation. Adam Mortara, SFFA's lawyer, argued that while Asian-Americans outperformed other groups on academic measures, they received low "personal" rating scores due to "racial stereotyping." "The law and common sense tell us skin color has nothing to do with your personal qualities or likability," he said.

Harvard's lawyers denied the charge and said that while it does consider race as an admissions factor, it does so legally and not in the "personal" ratings. William Lee, a lawyer for Harvard, argued SFFA's real goal was to "change the law" to bar any consideration of race, which would cause a "drastic" drop in black and Hispanic students on campus. "That result would be wrong legally," he said. "It would be wrong morally."

(With inputs from agencies.)

Download The Devdiscourse News App for Latest News.


TRENDING

OPINION/BLOG/INTERVIEW

Future of Food: Technology fostering the road to global food security

Technological innovation can help address most of the pressing issues facing the world today including food security by enhancing productivity, improving financial services, managing resources, addressing environmental concerns, etc....

Conspiracy theories on COVID 19: Legislators, Scientists, and Journalists all joined the Caravan

Conspiracy theories are not new for virus epidemics. There have been conspiracy theories on HIV-AIDS, Polio Vaccines, Ebola Virus, and several other diseases as well. However, what makes the 2019 Novel Coronavirus different from others is ...

Now it’s a war, Uganda deploys army to combat locust swarms

Its for the first time after 1986, the locust swarms have attacked Uganda twice in a season. With the increasing number of countries of Africa under attack by locust swarms, the problem seems to have taken a regional paradigm. Its very diff...

Top 10 Fake News, Myths and Realities on 2019 Novel Coronavirus COVID 19

With nearly 1500 deaths by January 14 and around 65,000 infections in China, the Novel Coronavirus 2019 has become one of the worst health epidemics of the 21st Century. However, 8,573 people have been cured but the rumor mongers are a...

Videos

Latest News

Bucks end Thunder's 5-game win streak in blowout fashion

Giannis Antetokounmpo scored 32 points to lead the Milwaukee Bucks to a 133-86 home blowout of the Oklahoma City Thunder on Friday night. It was the Bucks third win of 40-or-more points this season, tying Milwaukee for the NBA record for mo...

Malaysian rivals Mahathir and Anwar ally again amid turmoil

Malaysias Mahathir Mohamad will stand for prime minister on behalf of the former ruling coalition, he said on Saturday, less than a week after he quit and plunged the country into political turmoil. That meant that Mahathir, who as interim ...

Horton says bitter feud with Sun never personal after drug ban

Sydeny, Feb 29 AFP Australian champion swimmer Mack Horton insisted Saturday his bitter feud with Sun Yang was never personal and always about ensuring the sport was clean after the Chinese star was banned for eight years The Olympic 400m g...

Sri Lanka opt to bat against India in Women's T20 World Cup

Sri Lanka skipper Chamari Athapaththu won the toss and elected to bat against India in their Womens T20 World Cup match, here on SaturdayIndia, who have already qualified for the semifinals with three wins in a row, are unchangedTeams Indi...

Give Feedback