International Development News
Development News Edition

Australian prosecutors argue no grounds for ex-Vatican treasurer's final sex crimes appeal


Australian prosecutors argue no grounds for ex-Vatican treasurer's final sex crimes appeal
Image Credit: Wikimedia Commons

Prosecutors have urged Australia's High Court to refuse to hear a final appeal by former Vatican treasurer George Pell against his convictions for sexually abusing two 13-year-old boys in the late 1990s. In opposing arguments put by Pell's lawyers to Australia's highest court, prosecutors said there was no error in the approach taken by the Victorian state Court of Appeal.

The state appellate court upheld Pell's convictions, in a 2-1 ruling in August, on five charges of abusing the two boys at St Patrick's Cathedral in Melbourne when he was archbishop there. "The appeal raises no question of law of public importance," the prosecutors said in a filing to the High Court on Tuesday. The facts of the case were "carefully and thoroughly explored by the majority of the Court of Appeal", they said.

Pell's lawyers have seven days to respond, after which a panel of High Court judges will decide whether to hear the appeal, a High Court spokesman said. That decision can be made just on the submitted applications or following a hearing. The earliest the case could be heard would be in 2020, should the court decide to take on the appeal.

Pell is the highest-ranking Catholic worldwide to be convicted of child sex offenses. He was jailed in March for six years and will be eligible for parole in October 2022, when he will be 81. Two of the three judges at the Victorian appeal court ruled that "it was open to the jury to be satisfied beyond a reasonable doubt that Cardinal Pell was guilty of the offenses charged".

Pell's lawyers argued at his trial that it was impossible for him to have committed the offenses in light of all the activity that went on after mass in the priests' sacristy area of the cathedral, where the offences were said to have occurred. Pell's lawyers said in his leave to appeal to the High Court that the Court of Appeal's majority, in believing his accuser, had incorrectly shifted the burden of proof to the defense to show that the offenses were impossible.

Prosecutors said in response "there was little evidence that approached what could be described as an 'alibi'" and the account of Pell's accuser was backed by evidence, including his detailed description of the priests' sacristy, which was off-limits to choirboys.

Also Read: German prosecutors press charges against current and former VW CEOs

(This story has not been edited by Devdiscourse staff and is auto-generated from a syndicated feed.)


TRENDING

OPINION/BLOG/INTERVIEW

EdTech: A technical approach to flexible and cost-effective education

Its hight time for the world to go for innovative approaches like e-learning over traditional learning methods that need physical infrastructure, long-term planning, and huge investment. ...

Blockchain-powered token empowering poverty-stricken cocoa farmers

An average cocoa farmer earns as little as USD 1 per day which is significantly below the United Nations poverty line of USD 1.90 per day but that can change with the blockchain-powered token....

'No escape from telephones', this 1953 prediction actually comes true

In 1953, a telephone company chief predicted that therell be no escape from telephones in the future....

With Ayodhya verdict, CJI starts clearing high profile pending cases

Ending all the speculations, the Chief Justice of India Mr. Ranjan Gogoi who is due to retire on November 17 decided to deliver the verdict in Ayodya dispute at 10.30 am on Saturday which is not a working day for the Supreme Court. This is ...

Videos

Latest News

NBA roundup: Doncic scores 42 in triple-double

Luka Doncic poured in a career-high 42 points, grabbed 11 rebounds and recorded 12 assists to lead the Dallas Mavericks to a 117-110 win over the visiting San Antonio Spurs on Monday for their second straight victory. The triple-double was ...

Climate change may double greenhouse gas emissions from freshwater lakes: Study

Climate change may cause the levels of greenhouse gases emitted by freshwater northern lakes to increase by between 1.5 and 2.7 times, according to a study. Researchers from the University of Cambridge in the UK noted that every drop of fre...

Four JeM associates, responsible for carrying out blast in J-K's Pulwama, arrested

Four associates of terror group Jaish-e-Mohammad JeM, who was responsible for carrying out a blast in Jammu and Kashmirs Pulwama district, have been arrested, police said on Tuesday. While investigating the terror attack that took place in ...

U.S. says South Korea can do more on costs after talks break down

U.S. Defense Secretary Mark Esper said on Tuesday he believed South Korea can and should contribute more on cost-sharing for hosting the U.S. military after Seoul broke off the talks earlier in the day following a public backlash. Asked if ...

Give Feedback