AI disruption hits freelancers: Who’s winning and who’s losing?

While it confirms that generative AI can replace certain types of jobs, it also underscores that AI is a tool rather than a full replacement for human expertise. Freelancers who embrace AI and adapt to its capabilities will be well-positioned to thrive in the new economy, while those who resist change may find it increasingly difficult to compete.


CO-EDP, VisionRICO-EDP, VisionRI | Updated: 04-02-2025 16:23 IST | Created: 04-02-2025 16:23 IST
AI disruption hits freelancers: Who’s winning and who’s losing?
Representative Image. Credit: ChatGPT

The rapid rise of generative AI, particularly large language models like ChatGPT, is reshaping labor markets across the world. While AI has increased productivity in many sectors, it has also disrupted traditional work structures, raising concerns about job displacement. Nowhere is this shift more evident than in the freelance economy, where businesses and individuals hire talent for short-term projects. A recent study titled "Winners and Losers of Generative AI: Early Evidence of Shifts in Freelancer Demand", published in the Journal of Economic Behavior and Organization, examines how the introduction of ChatGPT has influenced the demand for freelancers. Authored by Ole Teutloff, Johanna Einsiedler, Otto Kässi, Fabian Braesemann, Pamela Mishkin, and R. Maria del Rio-Chanona, the study presents a data-driven analysis of how generative AI has impacted different types of freelance jobs.

The research categorizes freelance jobs into three groups: substitutable (where AI can directly replace human labor), complementary (where AI enhances but does not replace human work), and unaffected (where AI has limited influence). By analyzing over 3 million job postings from a major online freelancing platform, the study tracks demand trends before and after the launch of ChatGPT. The findings reveal a nuanced transformation in the freelance job market, highlighting clear winners and losers. Notably, demand for freelance jobs that AI can fully automate, such as content writing, proofreading, and translation, has significantly declined. Meanwhile, AI-powered roles like chatbot development and machine learning engineering have seen a rise in demand.

One of the most striking results of the study is the sharp drop in demand for writing and translation jobs. Freelance roles involving blog writing, article creation, and copywriting declined by 20% to 50%, with the sharpest drops observed in short-term gigs of one to three weeks. Translation services, particularly those for Western European languages, also saw significant reductions in demand. This decline aligns with the ability of ChatGPT and similar AI models to generate human-like text with minimal input, reducing the need for businesses to hire freelance writers for basic content production. However, not all writing-related jobs suffered equally - specialized roles, such as fiction writing and technical writing, were less affected. The study suggests that while AI can replicate simple content, more nuanced, creative, or highly technical writing still requires human expertise.

In contrast, demand for complementary skill sets showed mixed trends. AI-powered chatbot development saw an astonishing 179% increase, reflecting businesses’ growing interest in integrating AI-driven solutions into customer service and marketing. Similarly, demand for machine learning programming rose by 24%. However, not all AI-related jobs experienced uniform growth. A particularly interesting finding is that while complementary jobs remained stable overall, the demand for novice freelancers within these job categories declined. This suggests that employers are now prioritizing experienced professionals over beginners, possibly because AI tools make it easier for skilled workers to accomplish tasks more efficiently, reducing the need for lower-tier freelancers.

The study also found that freelance jobs categorized as unaffected by AI, such as graphic design, software development, and legal consulting, showed little to no impact. While AI-powered tools have advanced in image generation, they had not yet significantly reduced demand for human designers at the time of the study. Similarly, programming roles requiring human problem-solving and decision-making remained in steady demand. This reinforces the idea that while AI can enhance productivity, it cannot completely replace expertise in many fields.

One of the more unexpected findings of the study is the shift in demand for short-term freelance gigs. The decline in substitutable jobs was primarily concentrated in shorter projects, suggesting that businesses are now using AI to handle quick, repetitive tasks rather than outsourcing them to freelancers. This raises questions about how AI will continue to influence gig work, particularly for those who rely on short-term contracts as their primary source of income. At the same time, long-term freelance projects remained stable, indicating that AI is not yet replacing sustained, complex human work.

The researchers employed a rigorous methodology, using BERTopic, an advanced NLP clustering tool, to categorize freelance jobs into 116 distinct skill clusters. They then applied GPT-4o to classify these clusters as substitutable, complementary, or unaffected. To measure the impact of ChatGPT’s release, the study utilized a difference-in-differences econometric model, comparing pre- and post-ChatGPT demand trends while controlling for external factors. The results provide one of the most comprehensive analyses of how generative AI is reshaping labor markets in real-time.

For freelancers, the findings of this study highlight both challenges and opportunities. Those working in content writing, translation, and similar fields will need to adapt by developing skills that AI cannot easily replicate. Specialization in niche writing domains, strategic content creation, and AI-assisted editing could be ways to remain relevant. Meanwhile, freelancers in AI-powered fields, such as chatbot development and machine learning, are in a strong position to capitalize on the growing demand for these services. The study also emphasizes the importance of upskilling - workers who integrate AI into their workflows, rather than competing directly against it, are more likely to succeed in the evolving job market.

The study’s conclusions offer critical insights for businesses and policymakers as well. While AI-driven automation is reducing demand for certain jobs, it is also driving demand in other areas, particularly those requiring AI-related expertise. Governments and industry leaders will need to consider how to support workers affected by these shifts, whether through reskilling programs, education initiatives, or policies that promote AI-human collaboration rather than outright replacement.

Ultimately, the study presents a balanced perspective on AI’s impact on freelance work. While it confirms that generative AI can replace certain types of jobs, it also underscores that AI is a tool rather than a full replacement for human expertise. Freelancers who embrace AI and adapt to its capabilities will be well-positioned to thrive in the new economy, while those who resist change may find it increasingly difficult to compete. The findings serve as an early but significant indicator of the broader transformations that AI is likely to bring to labor markets in the years ahead.

  • FIRST PUBLISHED IN:
  • Devdiscourse
Give Feedback