Businesses Are Going Digital, but Their Workforce Intelligence Is Stuck Behind
Businesses are rapidly digitizing employee records and meeting regulatory requirements, but advanced workforce analytics remain significantly underused. A study of 905 Slovak enterprises reveals a widening divide between the technologies companies have implemented and those managers consider essential for the future, exposing a fundamental weakness in the transition from administrative digitalization to strategic human capital management.
Businesses can digitize employee records and meet data protection requirements while remaining poorly equipped to turn workforce information into strategic decisions. Research on Slovak enterprises exposes this uneven transition: managers recognize the growing importance of digital tools, yet their reported implementation falls behind those expectations, particularly in advanced analytics.
Published in Systems, "Readiness of Enterprises to Implement Digital Technologies Within Human Capital Management" by Alžbeta Kucharčíková and Natália Bodorová examines this divide. The University of Žilina researchers present evidence that digital transformation in people management depends on more than acquiring software: organizations also need the capabilities to use it effectively.
The findings come from 905 valid enterprise questionnaires collected between December 2020 and February 2021. The research captures an earlier phase of digital adoption. It diagnoses uneven organizational readiness, rather than a measurement of where Slovak businesses stand today.
Compliance Leads, Strategic Analytics Trails
The study asked human resources managers, senior managers and business owners to assess eight digital technologies. Respondents rated current implementation and perceived future importance separately on five-point scales. The technologies ranged from personnel information systems and communication platforms to predictive analytics, biometric systems and digital solutions associated with European data protection requirements.
Digital solutions linked to the General Data Protection Regulation, or GDPR, received the highest average implementation rating, at 4.43. Digital interaction platforms followed at 3.62, with personnel information systems at 3.57. Big Data analytics ranked last at 2.90, below biometric data digitalization at 2.99 and predictive analytics at 3.11.
These scores describe reported levels of implementation, rather than percentages of enterprises adopting each technology. Their ordering nevertheless reveals a clear pattern: businesses were further advanced in compliance, communication and administrative record management than in technologies intended to extract deeper insights from workforce information. Digital adoption was substantial in some functions but uneven across others.
The authors report a statistically significant difference between GDPR-related implementation and Big Data analytics. They interpret this as evidence that external institutional pressure carries greater weight than internally motivated analytical investment. Legal obligations appear to provide a stronger immediate incentive for digital adoption than the prospect of improving strategic workforce decisions.
The survey did not directly investigate adoption drivers or barriers. Its evidence supports a narrower conclusion: technologies associated with mandatory compliance were more extensively implemented than advanced analytics. Explanations involving costs, skills shortages or managerial priorities remain interpretations informed by the literature discussed in the paper.
Recognizing Value Does Not Establish Readiness
Managers generally assigned greater future importance to technologies than their current implementation scores suggested. Personnel information systems rose from 3.57 for implementation to 3.76 for future importance. Predictive analytics increased from 3.11 to 3.34, while biometric data digitalization moved from 2.99 to 3.22. GDPR-related solutions remained unchanged at 4.43.
Big Data analytics recorded the largest gap, increasing from 2.90 to 3.17. Even with that increase, it remained the lowest-ranked technology for future importance. The distinction is significant: respondents anticipated a greater role for advanced analytics without placing it above established administrative and communication tools. Recognition of future value remained relative and selective.
The authors report statistically significant differences for five of the eight technologies assessed. Their detailed results therefore support a broad expectation gap, rather than an identical pattern across every category. A higher importance rating also records a managerial judgment; it does not demonstrate an approved investment, a deployment timetable or the capacity to implement a system.
Personnel information systems illustrate the difference between establishing a digital foundation and extending its use. The paper describes their potential to centralize employee information, support working-time management, identify training needs and improve recruitment. These functions can make workforce information more accessible, but the survey did not measure whether adopting enterprises actually achieved those operational benefits.
The sample covered enterprises of different sizes, sectors and ownership structures. Domestic ownership accounted for 66.63% of respondents, while foreign ownership represented 33.37%. Services supplied 49.39% of responses, manufacturing 31.16% and other sectors 19.45%. This breadth provides a varied view of business practices within Slovakia, although it cannot establish that the same patterns apply elsewhere.
Readiness encompasses technical resources, managerial competence and human capital development in the study's framework. The distinction helps explain why a business can score well on one application while remaining less prepared for another. A single label of digital maturity can obscure the differences between these organizational functions.
Skills and Trust Must Accompany Investment
The study's central managerial argument is that technological investment and workforce development need to proceed together. Purchasing analytical tools creates limited strategic value if employees cannot interpret their outputs or incorporate them into decisions. The authors consequently recommend combining digital infrastructure with continuous learning and the development of employee digital competencies.
For businesses, this points toward assessing the organizational work surrounding implementation: who will use a system, what information it will provide and which decisions it should support. This is a practical reading of the authors' recommendations, rather than a tested implementation model. The research does not identify a universal sequence of investments or quantify returns.
Biometric systems bring a different set of considerations. Their comparatively low implementation and higher future importance ratings indicate an unresolved adoption gap. Drawing on earlier research, the authors discuss privacy, identity theft, data misuse and ethical concerns as possible explanations for reluctance. Their survey, however, did not directly establish which concerns influenced individual enterprises.
Expanding biometric adoption therefore cannot automatically be treated as evidence of better people management. The paper's discussion places privacy protection and security alongside operational convenience. Its wider account of sustainable digital transformation also emphasizes people's ability to understand technologies, making trust and responsible data handling part of organizational capability rather than secondary implementation concerns.
For policymakers, the findings suggest that compliance requirements alone may leave advanced analytical capabilities underdeveloped. The authors' emphasis on education and managerial understanding supports attention to capability building alongside technology investment. The survey does not establish which public intervention would work best, nor does it estimate the effectiveness of subsidies, training schemes or advisory services.
The paper also discusses cognitive overload and employee stress through existing literature. These risks were not measured among the surveyed enterprises, but they qualify the assumption that adding digital tools necessarily improves working conditions. An approach centered on human capital must consider employees' capacity to absorb technological change alongside the administrative benefits organizations expect.
The authors connect this challenge to organizational resilience, arguing that better information and employee capabilities can support adaptation during disruption. This connection provides a strategic rationale for investment, but resilience itself was not measured as an outcome. The findings establish differences in reported technology use, rather than demonstrated improvements in crisis response.
For readers considering relevance beyond Slovakia, the value lies in the distinction between mandatory adoption and voluntary capability development. Applying that distinction in another economy would require local evidence. The research offers questions for comparison, without establishing the financing conditions, institutional pressures or workforce needs of other countries.
An Earlier Snapshot With Unfinished Questions
The research adds substantial enterprise evidence from a post-socialist economy that the authors describe as underrepresented in digital human capital management research. Its reported response rate was 77.88%, and its questionnaire achieved high internal consistency. These features strengthen its descriptive contribution, while leaving questions about actual performance and the causes of uneven adoption unresolved.
Time is a major constraint. Data collected during 2020–2021 cannot establish present adoption levels, particularly as the authors acknowledge that digital transformation may have accelerated afterward. The findings provide a baseline for comparison. They do not show whether enterprises subsequently narrowed the gaps, changed priorities or adopted technologies that were outside the original questionnaire.
Self-reported assessments introduce another limitation: managers' ratings were not objective audits of implementation. The paper also contains inconsistencies between some narrative statements and its detailed rankings, including descriptions of the least-used technology. Its reported averages place Big Data analytics last. These discrepancies warrant care when interpreting broad claims about digital maturity or comparing individual technologies.
Further research needs to examine adoption barriers directly, compare countries and track enterprises over time. The authors propose investigating organizational, technological and human factors, including artificial intelligence and human–technology collaboration. The unresolved strategic question is whether greater digital ambition becomes usable workforce capability. Answering it requires evidence of implementation and outcomes beyond managers' expectations.
- FIRST PUBLISHED IN:
- Devdiscourse
Google News