Willing Teachers, Limited Support: What Holds Back Inclusive Education
Commitment to inclusive education can be strong even when the conditions for delivering it remain weak. Among teacher trainees at a Nigerian university, confidence in supporting diverse learners sits alongside concerns about resources, workload and curriculum flexibility. The resulting tension challenges any assumption that preparing willing teachers is enough to make classrooms inclusive.
Published in Trends in Higher Education, "Education for Inclusion: Unpacking Pre-Service Teachers' Perceived Readiness, Knowledge and Competencies" examines that divide. Its author, Mensah Prince Osiesi of Walter Sisulu University in South Africa, surveyed 260 education students at Federal University Oye-Ekiti in Nigeria, assessing their perceived readiness, knowledge, competence and obstacles to inclusive teaching.
The research identifies substantial enthusiasm for inclusion, but it also draws attention to the distance between personal confidence and practical delivery. Because participants assessed themselves, the findings describe how prepared they felt, rather than independently verified teaching performance. That distinction shapes what universities, schools and policymakers can reasonably take from the evidence.
Confidence Runs Ahead of Classroom Evidence
The study focused on third- and fourth-year students who had participated in compulsory teaching practice. Questionnaires were administered face to face during March–May 2025, and participants were selected purposively. Their responses offer insight into trainees with classroom exposure, although the design does not establish how effectively they taught learners with different needs.
Readiness ratings were consistently positive. Some 71.5% selected the highest-frequency response when asked whether they were prepared to teach inclusive classes, while 75.8% did so for teaching students with special needs. Willingness to develop further was especially strong: 88.5% selected the highest response category for wanting to learn more about making classes inclusive.
These responses suggest a receptive foundation for professional development. They also require careful interpretation because several readiness questions concern fairness, willingness and comfort rather than specific instructional tasks. A trainee can support the principle that every learner belongs without yet possessing the full range of techniques needed to make participation possible.
Nearly all respondents agreed or strongly agreed that they knew how to teach in inclusive classrooms. However, the questionnaire also included statements about willingness to learn and perceived influence on achievement. These responses cannot substitute for independent tests of understanding or evidence of learner progress.
Osiesi interprets the coexistence of positive self-assessments and practical obstacles as a gap between readiness and implementation. The study suggests that confidence may reflect attitudes, aspirations and belief in personal effectiveness.
Broad Competence Conceals Specific Weaknesses
Participants generally rated their teaching capabilities favourably. For tailoring instruction to diverse learning needs, 49.6% considered themselves very competent and another 47.3% selected competent. Similar confidence appeared in evaluating progress, setting learning goals and using different teaching methods. The author therefore characterizes perceived competence as high across the areas examined.
Yet the responses were less uniform when communication was considered more closely. For nonverbal communication in school, 7.3% described themselves as not competent and 19.2% as barely competent. Together, these categories accounted for 26.5% of respondents, showing a more substantial weakness within an otherwise positive account of professional capability.
This variation gives teacher educators a more specific starting point than the overall conclusion that trainees feel prepared. The survey identifies areas for closer practical assessment, without establishing why difficulties exist. Observed teaching, structured feedback and mentor evaluations would be needed to determine whether the reported differences correspond to performance in classrooms.
The study also found no statistically significant differences between female and male respondents in perceived readiness, knowledge or competence. The reported probability values were approximately 0.18, 0.51 and 0.84, respectively. These findings support the author's recommendation that inclusive preparation should develop all trainees without relying on gender-based assumptions about their capabilities.
The comparison remains limited to this sample and these measures. Women represented 79.6% of respondents, while men accounted for 20.4%. An absence of statistically significant differences does not establish that gender never shapes professional experiences. It indicates that the survey did not detect such differences in the self-assessments examined.
Resources and Training Shape the Delivery Gap
Respondents' concerns extended beyond their own abilities. Resource constraints attracted agreement or strong agreement from 55%, excessive workload from 53.5%, and curriculum rigidity from 53.4%. Limited exposure to inclusive education or its theories drew agreement from 51.5%, while exactly half identified insufficient training support as a barrier.
These results complicate an explanation focused entirely on teacher motivation. A willingness to adapt instruction operates within limits imposed by time, materials and curricular expectations. The author argues that professional and institutional conditions can constrain sustained inclusive practice even where teachers endorse inclusion and believe they possess the necessary knowledge.
The paper's discussion places this tension within Nigeria's wider education context, where the literature it reviews describes policy commitments alongside uneven implementation. The survey itself does not audit national policy delivery. Its contribution is more focused: it records how one cohort perceives preparation and constraints while undertaking the transition toward professional teaching.
Osiesi recommends strengthening training in differentiated instruction, curriculum and assessment adaptation, assistive technology, collaboration and classroom management. Teaching practice should provide opportunities to apply these skills with diverse learners, supported by mentors and supervision. The emphasis is on connecting conceptual preparation to decisions trainees must make in real classrooms.
The inclusive pedagogy framework underpinning the research emphasizes understanding learner diversity, adapting teaching and believing that every student can succeed with appropriate support. This approach treats inclusion as an ongoing instructional responsibility, extending beyond placing learners together in the same classroom.
The curriculum described in the paper raises a further question about timing. Inclusive education is taught through a compulsory fourth-year module, yet 254 of the 260 respondents were third-year students. The study does not establish how this timing affected their preparation, but the sample cannot demonstrate the module's effectiveness across graduating trainees.
The author also recommends professional development for teacher educators and compulsory sensitization and training workshops before teaching practice. These proposals follow the reported need for stronger support, but their effectiveness remains untested within this research and would require separate evaluation in practice.
For universities and partner schools, the author recommends accessible resources, manageable workloads and curricular flexibility alongside stronger mentoring. For policymakers, these recommendations direct attention toward the relationship between teacher preparation and school conditions. The study does not compare interventions, calculate implementation costs or establish which combination would produce the greatest improvement.
Inclusion Requires Proof Beyond Self-Belief
The research adds evidence on perceived preparation in a Nigerian university, bringing readiness, knowledge, competence and barriers into the same assessment. Its questionnaire showed high internal consistency, supporting the coherence of the responses. However, a reliable self-report instrument can measure confidence consistently without establishing that confidence accurately represents classroom competence.
The sample also limits wider conclusions. Participants came from one deliberately selected institution, and 46.5% studied Guidance and Counselling. Only six respondents were fourth-year students. These concentrations mean that the results cannot reliably describe all Nigerian teacher trainees, differences across universities or the preparation of students approaching graduation in other disciplines.
Several reporting issues warrant caution. The stated March–May 2025 data collection period precedes the ethics approval date reported elsewhere in the paper. Insufficient training support is also described as exceeding the questionnaire midpoint, although its reported median equals that midpoint. These discrepancies require clarification rather than editorial assumptions about the intended information.
The wider development relevance concerns inclusive and equitable education, which the paper connects to the Sustainable Development Goals. For stakeholders elsewhere in the Global South, the Nigerian findings offer questions about training and institutional support, rather than evidence that identical conditions prevail. Any transfer of recommendations would require attention to local education systems.
Future research could combine larger, more representative samples with interviews, classroom observations and mentor assessments, building on the author's recommendation for qualitative or mixed methods. Following trainees into employment would help clarify whether confidence persists and develops into effective practice. Learner participation and achievement would provide evidence unavailable from professional self-assessments alone.
- FIRST PUBLISHED IN:
- Devdiscourse
Google News