Left Menu
Development News Edition

Lebanese have little hope blast probe will lead to truth

Lebanon's judicial investigation of the Beirut port explosion started with political wrangling over the naming of a lead investigator, military threats to jail leakers and doubts over whether a panel appointed along sectarian lines could be fully impartial.

PTI | Beirut | Updated: 14-08-2020 13:08 IST | Created: 14-08-2020 12:55 IST
Lebanese have little hope blast probe will lead to truth
Representative image Image Credit: Twitter (UNHABITAT)

Lebanon's judicial investigation of the Beirut port explosion started with political wrangling over the naming of a lead investigator, military threats to jail leakers and doubts over whether a panel appointed along sectarian lines could be fully impartial. So for many Lebanese, their greatest hope for credible answers about the blast that wrecked much of their capital may lie with outsiders: the French forensic police who have joined the probe and FBI investigators are expected to take part.

French teams have pressed ahead at their work, sending divers into the underwater crater, taking explosives samples and preparing recommendations for both French and Lebanese magistrates. Among the French judicial police on the case are men and women who responded after the 2004 tsunami in Japan, the 2010 earthquake in Haiti, and the November 2015 and Bastille Day 2016 terror attacks in France. The Beirut explosion lies at the crossroads of a disastrous accident and a crime scene. It still was not known what sparked the fire that ignited nearly 3,000 tonnes of ammonium nitrate that were stored for years in Beirut's port next to densely populated residential areas. Documents have emerged that show the country's top leadership and security officials were aware of the stockpile.

Search and rescue crews flew in from around the world in the immediate aftermath and found themselves looking at a scene that was both familiar and yet strangely alien. "In an earthquake, it's easier because we can understand ... how it moves. But in this case, we didn't have enough elements to understand what happened," said Alberto Boanini, a member of the Italian rescue team. The team has seen its share of quakes and forest fires, but nothing quite like the port in Beirut, where he said it was hard to fathom what could level it so completely.

Many Lebanese want the probe taken out of the hands of their own government, having learned from past experience that the long-entrenched political factions, notorious for corruption, won't allow any results damaging to their leadership to come to light. The explosion killed more than 175 people, injured at least 6,000, and left tens of thousands homeless. Paris sent judicial police because a French architect was among the dead, and French law gives jurisdiction for an investigation if a citizen dies abroad under questionable circumstances.

But the French investigators work only at the invitation of the Lebanese, and their orders are confidential. French officials say they have the access they need but will not say whether their inquiry can extend to questioning witnesses or requesting documents. They hand over their findings to the Lebanese, but keep a mirror copy for a French inquiry. The FBI is also joining at Lebanese authorities' invitation.

Top Lebanese officials, including President Michel Aoun, have rejected calls for an independent probe, describing it as "a waste of time" and suggesting it would be politicised. In its last decision before resigning under pressure, six days after the explosion, Prime Minister Hassan Diab's government referred the port explosion case to the Higher Judicial Council, Lebanon's highest justice authority, to carry out the investigation.

An argument then ensued with the outgoing justice minister over the investigation's lead judge. The outgoing minister proposed a figure whom the panel rejected as too close to Aoun's party. After wrangling back and forth, they settled on a compromise, Judge Fadi Sawwan, a former military investigating judge. The Council itself is made up of 10 people, eight of whom are appointed according to the interests of the various political factions and religious sects in line with Lebanon's sectarian power-sharing system.

The authorities have so far arrested at least 19 people in connection to the blast, including the head of the Customs Department and his predecessor, as well as the head of the port. Lebanese say they want to see top officials who knew about the existence of the ammonium nitrate being investigated.

"They will blame the small guys while the ones who are really responsible will get away with their crime, that's what will happen," said Jad, a 38-year-old computer engineer who declined to give his full name in line with his company's regulations not to discuss politics. "Look, it's simple. If this time there is no credible, serious investigation that will lead to the punishment of everyone responsible for this disaster, it is goodbye Lebanon. No one will ever want to live in this country again," he said, standing on a bridge overlooking the decimated port. He had come to inspect the damage.

Lebanese forensics expert Omar Nachabe said the public infighting about the name of the lead investigator is a bad sign that casts doubt on the credibility of any local investigation. "If I am a Lebanese citizen, my capital (city) has been destroyed. I want a quick and serious investigation, yet the government has not shown until now that it is up to the task," he told the local channel LBCI. He lamented the time wasted before the explosion was referred to the HJC and the bickering that continues till now.

Explosions have marked a grim timeline in Lebanon's modern history and have killed presidents, prime ministers and countless journalists and activists during the country's 1975-90 civil war and beyond..


TRENDING

OPINION / BLOG / INTERVIEW

Post-COVID-19 Nigeria needs a robust Health Management Information System to handle high disease burden

Nigeria is among a few countries that conceptualised a health management information system HMIS in the early 90s but implementation has been a challenge till date. Besides COVID-19, the country has a huge burden of communicable and non-com...

Morocco COVID-19 response: A fragile health system and the deteriorating situation

Learning from its European neighbors, Morocco imposed drastic measures from the initial stages of the COVID-19 outbreak to try to contain its spread. The strategy worked for a few months but the cases have surged after mid-June. In this sit...

COVID-19: Argentina’s health system inefficiencies exaggerate flaws of health information system

You can recover from a drop in the GDP, but you cant recover from death, was the straightforward mindset of Argentinas President Alberto Fernndez and defined the countrys response to COVID-19. The South American nation imposed a strict...

Rwanda’s COVID-19 response commendable but health information system needs improvement

Rwanda is consistently working to improve its health information system from many years. However, it is primarily dependent on the collection and reporting of health data on a monthly basis. Besides, evaluation studies on Rwandas HIS publis...

Videos

Latest News

Parliament dismisses Citizen newspaper’s claims

Parliament has dismissed the Citizen newspapers claims that it will fully open for physical meetings on 5 October 2020.In a statement on Thursday, Parliamentary spokesperson Moloto Mothapo said the report is replete with blatant falsehoods ...

Taiwan holds anti-landing drill on frontline island with China

Taiwans armed forces have held anti-landing drills on one of its offshore islands close to China amid rising tensions with Beijing, the islands defence ministry said on Friday, showing images of a cannon firing and soldiers loading the guns...

Cobra Kai Season 3: Will Ralph Macchio, William Zabka return? What more we know

Fans and martial arts enthusiasts are excited, as Cobra Kai Season will be back on screen soon. They are curious to know if any other celebrities from the classic movie will jump into the sequel series. Read further to know more on it.Will ...

Kannadigas invited to micro-blogging platform Koo

With the indigenously developed micro-blogging site Koo available in major Indian languages, including Kannada, its co-founder Aprameya Radhakrishna has called upon Kannadigas to join the platform. Koo has created a safe place for Kannadiga...

Give Feedback