Left Menu
Development News Edition

Rafale deal case: SC asks Centre to provide details on decision making process

Devdiscourse News Desk | New Delhi | Updated: 10-10-2018 22:02 IST | Created: 10-10-2018 19:30 IST
Rafale deal case: SC asks Centre to provide details on decision making process
The information should be furnished in a sealed cover and reach the court by October 29 -- the next date of hearing, the bench said. (Image Credit: Twitter)

The Supreme Court on Wednesday asked the government to disclose details of the decision-making process for the purchase of 36 Rafale fighter jets in a fly-away condition from France's Dassault Aviation.

A bench of Chief Justice Ranjan Gogoi, Justice Sanjay Kishan Kaul and Justice K.M. Joseph clarified that the information sought was not related to pricing or suitability of the jets.

The information should be furnished in a sealed cover and reach the court by October 29 -- the next date of hearing, the bench said.

The court also made it clear that it was not issuing a notice to the respondents.

The court sought information from the government as Attorney General K.K. Venugopal said the purchase of the French fighter aircraft concerned the national security and described the petition as a "political interest litigation" which had been filed when the government and opposition were locked in a severe political fight.

Urging the court not to entertain the plea as the purchase of Rafale aircraft was not judicially reviewable, Attorney General said: "It is not a PIL but a 'political Interest Litigation' coming on the eve of elections to state assemblies of Rajasthan, Madhya Pradesh, Chhattisgarh, Telangana and Mizoram."

The AG told the court that answers to the questions in Parliament were being selectively quoted to file the PIL which were politically coloured.

In response to a query from Chief Justice Gogoi, "if we ask you to give details minus technical details", the AG said that this could not be shown to anyone given the national security and other issues of defence involved in it.

Addressing the court, PIL petitioner advocates M.L. Sharma referred to the pricing of the aircraft that had been quoted at different points of time before different forums to drive the point that price being paid by India was high.

He also took the court through the history of the deal initially starting in 2008, the involvement of a corporate house before finally the deal for purchase of 36 Rafale aircraft in a fit-to-fly condition was signed.

However, the court asked another petitioner to limit his submission to the issues raised in his petition and not to "digress" from it.

"Don't digress from the issue, we will not hear you", CJI Gogoi told the lawyer appearing for the other petitioner.

(With inputs from agencies.)

Download The Devdiscourse News App for Latest News.



All party meeting - Blocking dialogue not culture of Bengal, Mamata needs to speak up

If that happens, history will record it as the dark age of Bengal....

Diya Jalao for COVID 19: How Modi put Power Grids and power warriors at risk?

While Prime Minister Narendra Modis staunch supporters are busy in search of hidden science behind the sudden announcement of 9minutes9pm campaign but his ignorance of the actual science has put the nation in another danger. The scientists ...

'Diya jalao' for COVID 19: Modi needs to practice his teachings and control fake news on social media

In his video message to the nation on Friday the Prime Minister talks about peoples collective power to win the invincible. However, he has made no concreate efforts to win over the confidence and represent the collective power of the polit...


Latest News

Some post pics with diyas, some rage against those bursting crackers on social media

While many posted pictures of lighting diya, some expressed anguish over bursting of crackers as the nation responded to Prime Minister Narendra Modis call for a nine-minute candlelight vigil on Sunday. Modi had called for a nine-minute can...

Mukesh Ambani, wife Nita Ambani join nation in fight against COVID-19

RIL chairman and managing director Mukesh Ambani and his wife Nita Ambani on Sunday night lit candles to mark Indias resilience to fight against COVID-19. Ambanis lit candles and earthen lamps at their residence -- Antilia -- after switchin...

B-town celebs stand in solidarity with frontline workers by lighting diyas, candles

Responding to Prime Minister Narendra Modis 9 pm, 9-min appeal to defeat the coronavirus in the country, B-town celebs turned off the lights in their houses and lighted earthen lamps across on Sunday night. Akshay Kumar shared a picture on ...

Electricity demand went down but frequecy was maintained during PM's 'switch off light' call: Power Minister RK Singh

Union Power Minister RK Singh has informed that demand for electricity supply went down during Prime Minister Narendra Modis switch off the light campaign at 9 pm on Sunday for few a minutes but the frequency was maintained and the voltage ...

Give Feedback