Judicial Conduct Panel Recommended to Probe Judge Aitken's Alleged Misconduct
Attorney-General Delegates Decision-Making to Justice Minister to Avoid Conflict of Interest.

- Country:
- New Zealand
The Judicial Conduct Commissioner has recommended the establishment of a Judicial Conduct Panel to investigate the alleged conduct of acting District Court Judge Ema Aitken during an incident on November 22, 2024. Attorney-General Judith Collins announced the recommendation today, emphasizing the importance of impartiality in handling the matter.
“I referred the matter of Judge Aitken’s alleged conduct to the Judicial Conduct Commissioner, who has since recommended a Judicial Conduct Panel to inquire into the events,” said Ms. Collins.
Due to her role in initiating the referral, Ms. Collins has delegated further decision-making to Justice Minister Paul Goldsmith. This step aims to avoid any perception of conflict of interest or bias. "Mr. Goldsmith will now consider the Commissioner’s recommendation," Ms. Collins confirmed, adding that no further comment would be made.
Background of the Alleged Incident
While the specifics of the alleged misconduct have not been disclosed publicly, the recommendation for a Judicial Conduct Panel signals the seriousness of the matter. Such panels are convened only when allegations against a judge warrant a thorough and formal inquiry.
The Judicial Conduct Panel will be tasked with investigating the circumstances of the November incident and providing a detailed report. This report will form the basis for any subsequent actions or decisions regarding Judge Aitken’s professional standing.
Maintaining Public Trust in the Judiciary
The Judicial Conduct Commissioner plays a critical role in maintaining public trust in the judiciary by ensuring allegations of misconduct are addressed transparently and fairly. Establishing a Judicial Conduct Panel reflects the judiciary’s commitment to accountability and upholding ethical standards.
What Comes Next
Justice Minister Paul Goldsmith will now review the recommendation and determine whether to establish the panel. If convened, the panel will conduct a comprehensive inquiry, hearing evidence and submissions before delivering its findings and recommendations.
Legal experts suggest that such inquiries are crucial to maintaining confidence in the judicial system, ensuring that judges are held to the highest standards of conduct.
By delegating the decision-making to Justice Minister Goldsmith, the government underscores its commitment to a fair and impartial process, reinforcing public confidence in the integrity of the judicial oversight system.
- READ MORE ON:
- Judith Collins
- Ema Aitken