Left Menu
Development News Edition

Europe's top court to rule on 'right to be forgotten' Google case on Sept. 24

Reuters | Brussels | Updated: 20-09-2019 22:04 IST | Created: 20-09-2019 21:59 IST
Europe's top court to rule on 'right to be forgotten' Google case on Sept. 24
Image Credit: Flickr

Europe's top court will rule on Sept. 24 whether Alphabet Inc unit Google must remove links to sensitive personal data worldwide or in Europe only in a case that pits privacy rights against the right of free speech. A second related dispute before the Luxembourg-based Court of Justice of the European Union (ECJ) is whether Google must automatically delete search results with sensitive information on a person's sex life or criminal convictions, among others.

The cases test the region's right to extend its laws beyond its borders and a ruling against Google may even embolden authoritarian governments to demand the removal of any topic they want, legal observers said. The first case centers on Google's dispute with France's privacy watchdog CNIL, which in 2015 told U.S.-based Google to delist sensitive information from internet search results globally upon request in what is called the "right to be forgotten".

CNIL fined Google 100,000-euros ($110,200) because it refused to comply. Google challenged the ruling at France's Council of State, which turned to the ECJ for guidance. Google won the backing of ECJ court adviser Maciej Szpunar earlier this year who said that the right to be forgotten should only be enforced in Europe and not globally. Judges follow such non-binding opinions in four out of five cases.

The issue is important because it affects conflicting fundamental rights, said Richard Cumbley, a partner at law firm Linklaters. "The case highlights the continuing conflict between national laws and the Internet which does not respect national boundaries," Cumbley said.

"It seems unlikely that the court would give the right to be forgotten global effect," he said. "This would create a serious clash with US concepts of freedom of speech and other states might also try and suppress search results on a global basis reducing Google's search engine to a list of the anodyne and inoffensive." A Google report showed that it removed 45 percent of the 3.3 million links from 845,501 requests received in the last five years since the ECJ enshrined the right to be forgotten in Europe in 2014.

The world's most popular internet search engine has previously warned of the dangers of over-reach by Europe. In a blog post two years ago, the company said there should be a balance between sensitive personal data and the public interest and that no one country should be able to impose its rules on citizens of another. The second case arose when CNIL rejected requests from four people to order Google to remove links found in internet searches using their names.

These included a satirical photomontage of a female politician; an article referring to someone as a public relations officer of the Church of Scientology; the placing under investigation of a male politician; and the conviction of someone for sexual assaults against minors. Court adviser Szpunar recommended that prohibitions on processing certain types of data should also apply to the operators of search engines.

The European Commission, Microsoft Corp, UK rights group Article 19, the Wikimedia Foundation Inc and the Reporters Committee for Freedom of the Press backed Google at a court hearing last year. The cases are C-507/17 Google and C-136/17 G.C. e.a.

($1 = 0.9076 euros)

Also Read: UPDATE 6-U.S. states launch antitrust probes of tech companies, focus on Facebook, Google



Canada’s COVID-19 pitfalls highlight need for integrated health information system

In the globalized world of today where outbreaks can spread far and wide within a matter of days, a global-level integrated health information system is ideal but Canadas provincial barriers show that the country lags much behind in deployi...

Pandemic must be impetus, not obstacle, for clean water access

To make matters worse, there are suspicions that the inadequacy of wastewater treatment methods in California, the rest of the USA, and indeed around the world may help to propagate the disease even more widely. ...

3D printing and the future of manufacturing post COVID-19

The on-demand, customizable, and localized manufacturing of product components facilitated by 3D printing has the potential to redefine manufacturing but there are certain technical, mechanical, and legal limitations that, unless ...

How UK’s 'best prepared' healthcare system failed to gauge COVID-19

The UK is proud of their public health system and its unlike any other country as around 90 percent of British public supports the founding principles of National Health Service. But without accurate data being available to stakeholders in ...


Latest News

British mall owner Intu puts Trafford Centre for sale

Trafford Centre, one of Britains major shopping centres, is being put up for sale, a source familiar with the matter told Reuters late Tuesday, in less than two months after its parent company Intu Properties collapsed into administration.T...

U.S. Big Ten, Pac-12 postpone fall college football, other sports, due to COVID-19

Two of the five wealthiest U.S. college sports conferences postponed the fall football season on Tuesday because of the COVID-19 pandemic, a critical blow to both an iconic American cultural tradition and a multibillion-dollar entertainment...

New Zealand delays election process as it plunges back into coronavirus lockdown

New Zealand Prime Minister Jacinda Ardern on Wednesday delayed a key step toward next months general election, as the country was plunged back into lockdown after the discovery of the first COVID-19 cases in more than three months.Ardern sa...

Dube nets two goals as Flames top Stars

Dillon Dube scored twice and Rasmus Andersson netted the game winner as the Calgary Flames beat the Dallas Stars 3-2 to take the opening game in their first-round Stanley Cup playoff series Tuesday in Edmonton. With the score tied late in t...

Give Feedback