Left Menu
Development News Edition

UPDATE 4-Exxon's lawyer calls lawsuit a 'cruel joke' as climate change fraud trial ends


UPDATE 4-Exxon's lawyer calls lawsuit a 'cruel joke' as climate change fraud trial ends
Image Credit:

Lawyers for New York state and Exxon Mobil Corp delivered closing arguments in a closely watched trial accusing the oil company of hiding from investors the true cost of addressing climate change. The case, filed in October 2018 in Manhattan state court, was the first of several climate-related lawsuits against major oil companies to go to trial.

It featured testimony from investors, experts and former Exxon Chief Executive Rex Tillerson, who denied the allegations against the company. New York's attorney general alleges that Exxon caused investors to lose up to $1.6 billion by falsely telling them it had properly evaluated the impact of future climate regulations on its business. A verdict is expected within the next 40 days.

Exxon's lawyer said on Thursday the case was "meritless" and that the state failed to offer testimony from any investor who was misled. "The case is almost a joke," Theodore Wells said. "But it's a cruel joke, your honor, because the reputations of a lot of people have been hurt and disparaged by the bringing of the complaint."

A lawyer for the state said the case came down to whether Exxon had adequately disclosed the cost of climate change. "The question here isn't whether Exxon employees are good people or even were trying their best," Jonathan Zweig said.

He told the court that the state was dropping two of its four fraud claims and would limit its closing argument to claims brought under the Martin Act, a law that gives the New York attorney general's office broad power to pursue securities fraud cases without having to prove intent to defraud. "The question in this case is whether Exxon's disclosures were accurate, and the evidence shows they were not," Zweig said.

The attorney general has said the company used a "proxy cost" of up to $80 per ton of carbon emissions in wealthy countries by 2040, but internally used figures as low as $40 per ton or none at all. Tillerson testified that the proxy cost represented "macro level" assessment of the likely effect of future carbon regulations around the world on demand for fossil fuels, and was incorporated into a data guide used throughout Exxon.

Separately, he said, the company evaluated greenhouse gas costs at a "micro level" for specific projects, when appropriate. Wells said the attorney general's case wrongly conflated proxy costs with those separate, project-specific costs.

Last month, just two days after the New York trial began, Massachusetts filed a similar lawsuit accusing Exxon of misleading investors and consumers for decades about the role fossil fuels play in climate change. Both Massachusetts and New York began investigating Exxon after news reports in 2015 saying company scientists had determined that fossil fuel combustion must be reduced to mitigate the impact of climate change.

Exxon and other oil companies including BP Plc, Chevron Corp and Royal Dutch Shell Plc face lawsuits by cities and counties across the United States seeking funds to pay for seawalls and other infrastructure to guard against rising sea levels brought on by climate change. The companies have said in court filings that they cannot be held liable for climate change.

Also Read: UPDATE 1-New York City Council votes to ban sale of foie gras

(This story has not been edited by Devdiscourse staff and is auto-generated from a syndicated feed.)


TRENDING

OPINION/BLOG/INTERVIEW

JNU Administration's 100-meter challenge before JNUSU

For the first time in its history, Jawaharlal Nehru University JNU Administration is seeking permanent deployment of local police to keep protesting students at 100 meters away from the Administrative Block. It would be interesting to see h...

Sentiment Analysis of Twitter users during COP25: Governments losing trust on Climate Action

Sentiment analysis of Twitter users during COP25 in Madrid, being held from December 2-13, shows widespread fear on climate change due to global warming but almost no trust on governments in meeting the emission targets. In the analysis the...

These innovators are making humanitarian response more efficient

These alarming trends prompt a call for the world to not only address the ongoing crisis but also to adopt innovative approaches to fulfill the growing humanitarian needs in such emergencies. ...

Hyderabad Encounter: A sentiment analysis of public mood on day of encounter

Sentiment analysis of twitter users revealed that they showered salutes on Hyderabad police for eliminating alleged gang rapists of the veterinary doctor but only a few believe in cops version of successive events leading to encounter....

Videos

Latest News

SPORTS SCHEDULE AT 7:30 p.m. GMT/2:30 p.m. ET

Here are the top sports stories and upcoming coverage plans for Reuters text service as of 730 p.m. GMT230 p.m. ET. For a full schedule of news and events, go to our editorial calendar on Reuters Connect httpswww.reutersconnect.complanning....

Some people at Jamia protest came prepared for arson: Delhi Police

Delhi Police on Sunday alleged that some people who were part of the agitation against the amended citizenship law came prepared for arson and torched vehicles. Deputy Commissioner of Police Southeast Chinmoy Biswal said nearly 1,500 people...

Reuters U.S. Sports Schedule at 2:26 PM EDT on Sunday, Dec 15

- - - - COLLEGE BASKETBALLGame coverage Sunday Central Connecticut at Boston College 100 p.m. Gardner-Webb at Virginia Tech 130 p.m. NC State at UNC Greensboro 300 p.m. Oklahoma State at Houston 300 p.m. SIU-Edwardsville at Northwestern 400...

Govt making its presence felt through oppression on students, journalists: Priyanka

Congress leader Priyanka Gandhi Vadra accused the Modi government on Sunday of being cowardly as it feared to hear the voice of people and was making its presence felt through oppression on students and journalists. In a tweet late on Sunda...

Give Feedback