Left Menu
Development News Edition

HC issues notice to Guj govt on 'lok rakshak dal' recruitment

They said over 5,000 women candidates were appointed after lowering cut-off marks at the fag end of the recruitment process, and that too after final selection list-merit list was published and only appointment letters were to be issued. Creation of 2,485 supernumerary posts is an example of "reverse discrimination," as all such posts were created only for women candidates, especially given that the division bench of HC had earlier quashed and set aside 33 per cent horizontal reservation for women.

PTI | Ahmedabad | Updated: 25-09-2020 18:38 IST | Created: 25-09-2020 18:38 IST
HC issues notice to Guj govt on 'lok rakshak dal' recruitment

The Gujarat High Court on Friday issued notice to the state government in a plea filed by 187 male candidates who had applied for the post of 'lok rakshak dal' (LRD, or police constable and jail sepai) seeking setting aside of the entire recruitment process as well as appointments made and to begin it afresh. The court of Justice AC Rao issued notice to the state government on the plea filed by male candidates who failed to make it to the merit list by a few marks.

They said the recruitment, in which the government created 2,485 supernumerary posts for women candidates and separate merit lists for different categories, "suffers from manifest arbitrariness, gross discrimination and contempt of court of a deliberate, willful and intentional nature". The matter will come up for hearing on October 6.

The petitioners said they are meritorious and would have been appointed as per law but for the "illegal and unconstitutional process" culminating in the appointment of more than 12,000 LRD candidates. They said over 5,000 women candidates were appointed after lowering cut-off marks at the fag end of the recruitment process, and that too after final selection list-merit list was published and only appointment letters were to be issued.

Creation of 2,485 supernumerary posts is an example of "reverse discrimination," as all such posts were created only for women candidates, especially given that the division bench of HC had earlier quashed and set aside 33 per cent horizontal reservation for women. The process, hence, violates Article 16 of the Constitution, they said.

Supernumerary posts cannot be created on such a large scale, they further said. The petitioners said there should have been a common merit list to fill up the posts in different categories and not separate lists as has been done in the present case.

"This sort of compartmentalised merit list strikes at the very root of the recruitment process and runs contrary to how the process, keeping in mind qualification and eligibility criteria, merit/selection list, is to be prepared. "If the appointments are collectively, cumulatively and in a common thread attended to, all the irregularities and illegalities will come to fore," said the plea filed through lawyer Anand Yagnik.

The petitioners said the recruitment process was not done in accordance with the order passed by the division bench of the High Court last month. The division bench had last month quashed and set aside a clause in a government resolution issued by the state's General Administration Department with regards to 33 per cent "horizontal reservation" for women candidates in the same LRD recruitment.

The division bench had in its order said that while a general category woman is not entitled to compete for posts reserved for OBC, SC and ST women candidates, all women, irrespective of whether they belong, or do not belong, to the reserved category, are entitled to compete for posts the general category..


TRENDING

OPINION / BLOG / INTERVIEW

New farm bills in India: Focusing on farms or farmers?

... ...

Kenya’s COVID-19 response: Chaos amid lack of information

Confusing numbers and scanty information on how effective curfews and lockdowns have been in breaking transmission have amplified coordination and planning challenges in Kenyas response to COVID-19. Without accurate data, it is impossible t...

Farkhad Akhmedov: Calculating the price of impunity from the law

In insistences such as the battle over the Luna, Akhmedov has resorted to extreme legal machinations to subvert the High Courts decision and keep his assets from being seized. ...

Guinea’s elections hearken back to the autocracy and violence of its past

... ...

Videos

Latest News

FTSE 100 slips to 5-month low as British Airways, virus concerns weigh

Londons FTSE 100 hit a five-month low on Thursday as glum quarterly reports from firms, including British Airways-owner IAG, weighed on sentiment ahead of a parliament address by finance minister Rishi Sunak on the economic outlook. The blu...

ONGC wins 7 oil blocks, OIL 4 in latest bid round

State-owned Oil and Natural Gas Corp ONGC has won seven out of the 11 oil and gas exploration blocks offered for bidding in the latest licensing round, upstream regulator Directorate General of Hydrocarbons DGH said Thursday. Oil India Ltd ...

China says no timetable for Boeing 737 MAX's return to service in the country

Head of Chinas aviation regulator said on Thursday that authorities have not set a timetable on when Boeing Cos 737 MAX jet would return to service in the country. It is happy to see the aircraft resume commercial operations in China if the...

Hong Kong stocks inch higher as financials lend support

Hong Kong stocks ended marginally higher on Thursday, aided by gains in heavyweight financial firms. At the close of trade, the Hang Seng index was up 31.71 points, or 0.13, at 24,786.13. The Hang Seng China Enterprises index rose 0.07 to 1...

Give Feedback