Left Menu
Development News Edition

Modi likely to launch Universal Basic Income for poor ahead of general elections


Modi likely to launch Universal Basic Income for poor ahead of general elections
While it is still not clear who the actual beneficiaries will be and what the threshold levels will be, it is clear that the government is willing to tweak its fiscal math, optics in the run-up to the polls being paramount.

With Rahul Gandhi throwing down the gauntlet at the ruling BJP dispensation saying that he will usher in a minimum income guarantee scheme if he comes to power, Prime Minister Narendra Modi may be compelled to roll out a Universal Basic Income scheme for the poorest of the poor. With both sides of the bipolar divide getting sharpened, BJP may now have to launch a pilot project through the mechanism of the budget. While it is still not clear who the actual beneficiaries will be and what the threshold levels will be, it is clear that the government is willing to tweak its fiscal math, optics in the run-up to the polls being paramount.

The 2016-17 Economic Survey had clearly indicated proposed income support for the bottom 75 per cent. The question is how the government will balance its financial equilibrium given that food subsidy is close to Rs 1,70,000 crore while MNREGA is an additional Rs 55,000 crore. Fiscal deficit breach is unsustainable at this precise moment in our journey to achieve financial equilibrium.

Estimated support of Rs 6,540 crore-Rs 7,620 crores is on the anvil if the government goes ahead with UBI. The UPA had rolled out UBI as a pilot project across 8 villages in Madhya Pradesh as far back as 2011-12. The big question remains how many districts will form a part of this new pilot project once it is announced in the budget.

Equally, will it be for those people designated below the poverty line, will individuals or households be the targeted beneficiaries? And of course most importantly, one cannot have food subsidy and UBI running in parallel, it can only be one or the other. In India, a rapid expansion of direct cash transfers linked to the national biometric database and small basic income experiments has galvanized an extensive debate on a UBI.

Carnegie India reckons supporters' claim that no-strings-attached payments will be an effective antidote to India's underperforming anti-poverty programmes and leaky, distortionary subsidies. Critics worry that they will undermine an already-fragile social security architecture, cause workers to drop out of the labour force and encourage wasteful spending.

The pre-budget Economic Survey of 2016-17 provides the most exhaustive treatment thus far of implementing an Indian UBI. It finds that India's largest welfare schemes are poorly targeted; in comparison, it argues that a UBI distributed directly into bank accounts will limit pilferage, be easier to administer, and prove a more effective anti-poverty intervention.

The 2016-17 Economic Survey deserved praise for bringing substantial rigour to the debate, thrusting a UBI into the national spotlight and prudently concluding that the time has not yet come for implementation.

However, should future Indian policymakers wish to implement a UBI, the survey's central design features offer a weak foundation. If enacted upon without deeper analysis, debate, or sufficient evidence demonstrating improvement in development outcomes, the Economic Survey's blueprint for an Indian UBI will produce underwhelming results.

(With inputs from agencies.)

Download The Devdiscourse News App for Latest News.


TRENDING

OPINION/BLOG/INTERVIEW

Conspiracy theories on COVID 19: Legislators, Scientists, and Journalists all joined the Caravan

Conspiracy theories are not new for virus epidemics. There have been conspiracy theories on HIV-AIDS, Polio Vaccines, Ebola Virus, and several other diseases as well. However, what makes the 2019 Novel Coronavirus different from others is ...

Top 10 Fake News, Myths and Realities on 2019 Novel Coronavirus COVID 19

With nearly 1500 deaths by January 14 and around 65,000 infections in China, the Novel Coronavirus 2019 has become one of the worst health epidemics of the 21st Century. However, 8,573 people have been cured but the rumor mongers are a...

Handling fake news Infodemic in time of Coronavirus epidemic

Social media has provided a platform where everybody can disseminate his her views without any supervision. Its excellent if the message is genuine but misinformation is equally disastrous. Health is such a topic where every Tom and Harry c...

Sentiment Analysis on Budget 2020: Long shot for solution to economic worries?

Industries and individuals alike had high expectations from the government to take tangible steps but the budget 2020 seems to have failed expectations....

Videos

Latest News

UPDATE 4-Gunman kills 9 in German shisha bar rampage

A gunman shot nine people dead in two shisha bars in an overnight rampage through a German city before, police believe, returning home and killing himself. Newspaper Bild said he had expressed extreme right-wing views in a letter of confess...

Eating fruits, vegetables linked to lessening of menopause symptoms: Study

A diet rich in fruits and vegetables may lessen various menopause symptoms, according to a new study which may lead to better clinical food recommendations for women. The study, published in the journal Menopause, said although hormone ther...

S.Korea's Hynix says 800 workers to stay home after trainee had contact with virus patient

South Korean chipmaker SK Hynix said on Thursday that 800 of its workers had quarantined themselves as a precautionary measure to prevent the spread of the coronavirus, but its production in the city of Icheon has not been affected. The mov...

UPDATE 6-Bloomberg comes under scathing attack at first Democratic presidential debate in Nevada

Michael Bloomberg faced a barrage of attacks at his first Democratic presidential debate on Wednesday, as his rivals assailed the free-spending and fast-rising billionaire over his record on race, history of sexist comments and the use of h...

Give Feedback