Left Menu
Development News Edition

UPDATE 2-Trump administration weakens mercury rule for coal plants

Reuters | Updated: 20-04-2020 20:18 IST | Created: 20-04-2020 20:18 IST
UPDATE 2-Trump administration weakens mercury rule for coal plants

The Trump administration on Thursday withdrew the legal justification for an Obama-era rule that forced coal-fired power plants to cut their mercury emissions, saying the cost of compliance far outweighed the public health benefits.

The move, which was slammed by environmentalists and utility companies, leaves the so-called Mercury and Air Toxic Standards in place for now, but could pave the way for lawsuits from companies opposed to it and prevent similar regulations from being implemented in the future. "It's honest accounting," Environmental Protection Agency Administrator Andrew Wheeler said in a conference call with reporters announcing the move.

At issue is a 2016 conclusion by then-President Barack Obama’s EPA that forcing coal-fired power plants to slash mercury output was justified because savings to consumers on healthcare costs would exceed compliance costs. Mercury can harm pregnant women and put infants and children at risk of developmental problems. The calculations used at the time, however, accounted for how pollution-control equipment at coal plants would reduce emissions of particulate matter and other harmful substances that come out of smokestacks, in addition to mercury.

Republican President Donald Trump's EPA said in 2018 it had reviewed the justification for the rule and believed it was inappropriate to have included the benefits of reducing emissions other than mercury. It proposed withdrawing the justification. Thursday's announcement finalized that proposal. The revised analysis of the rule estimated the cost to coal- and oil-fired power plants to be between $7.4 billion and $9.6 billion a year, compared with quantified health benefits of just $4 million to $6 million a year - accounting for mercury alone.

"The more transparent we are about the science behind our regulations, and the costs and the benefits behind our regulations, the more acceptance we will see across the board from the American public," Wheeler said. He emphasized that the rule's requirements had not changed and said the EPA would defend it if challenged in court.

But he added that the changes "foreshadow" the agency's approach to an upcoming cost-benefit regulation. 'ABSOLUTE ABOMINATION'

Environmentalists decried the move, saying it undermined clean air protections vital to protecting public health. "This is an absolute abomination," said Natural Resources Defense Council President Gina McCarthy, who served as EPA administrator under Obama. "The only ones to benefit from this are powerful polluters - at the expense of our health, and our children's health."

Electric utilities pushed back on the potential loosening of mercury requirements, saying they had invested billions to cut emissions of the dangerous pollutant, and had sought and secured rate increases from power consumers to cover the costs. "The repeal of the underlying legal basis for MATS introduces new uncertainty and risk for companies that still are recovering the costs for installing those control technologies," Utility trade group Edison Electric Institute said in a statement.

But the U.S. coal industry has railed against the mercury rule, and blamed it for putting hundreds of coal-fired power plants out of business in recent years. The National Mining Association, which represents coal-company interests, applauded the move.

"While the coal-fueled plants that were forced out of operation by this illegal rule can’t be resurrected, it’s an important lesson for the future," the trade group said in a statement. Trump made it a central promise of his 2016 campaign to revive the U.S. coal industry, which he said had been unfairly targeted by Obama's climate and environmental policies.


TRENDING

OPINION / BLOG / INTERVIEW

‘Discounted Deaths’ and COVID 19: Anthropology of Death and Emotions

Death is a social event rather than the mere cessation of biological functions. As seen by anthropologists, death is not just physical but intensely social, cultural, and political....

Indigenous knowledge of communities a must for maximizing impact of community work

Generally, it has been observed that the majority of the academicians in higher education institutions neglect the wisdom of community people and throw their weight around thinking that they know everything and the community knows nothing. ...

In rebuking FBR, Pakistan’s courts take a stand for public health

The system, if implemented effectively, will allow Pakistans revenue service to combat the illicit trade in tobacco products and potentially add hundreds of millions of dollars to the states budget each year. ...

Dissecting how COVID-19 is catalyzing the trajectory of New World Order

The ensuing pandemic of COVID-19 has hit the globalization in two ways firstly, shrinking the importance of globalization as an economic force by curtailing mobility through worldwide lockdowns, and secondly, rejuvenating the idea of indig...

Videos

Latest News

UNHCR working to find solutions for urban refugees in Africa during COVID19 crisis

Refugees in urban areas across the East, Horn and Great Lakes region of Africa are struggling to meet their most basic needs as the economic impact of COVID19 begins to take hold.UNHCR, the UN Refugee Agency is working closely with governme...

Motor racing-Audi suspends Formula E racer Abt for esports deception

Audi suspended German Formula E driver Daniel Abt with immediate effect on Tuesday after he cheated in an official esports race by getting a professional gamer to take his place.Abt issued an apology on Sunday for the deception in Saturdays...

Uber cuts 600 jobs in India as lockdown hits business

Uber Technologies Inc has cut about 600 jobs in India as part of plans to reduce its global workforce by 23, the company said on Tuesday, joining local rival Ola as the COVID-19 pandemic crushes demand for app-based cab services.Last week, ...

Cong arranges bus for UP guest workers to go to Lucknow

The Congress in Telangana on Tuesday said 40 migrant workers stranded here due to the COVID-19 lockdown have been sent to Lucknow in a bus arranged by it. State Congress president and Lok Sabha member N Uttam Kumar Reddy flagged off the bus...

Give Feedback