Left Menu
Development News Edition

What is bribery? Trump impeachment hearing highlights Democrats’ dilemma


What is bribery? Trump impeachment hearing highlights Democrats’ dilemma
US President Donald Trump (File photo) Image Credit: ANI

What is bribery? The question was robustly debated by legal experts on Wednesday during a congressional hearing in the impeachment inquiry of U.S. President Donald Trump.

The back-and-forth highlights a dilemma faced by Democrats seeking to remove Republican Trump from office - whether to make "bribery" one of the formal charges or to use broader wording such as "abuse of power." The inquiry focuses on Trump's requests that Ukraine conduct investigations that could benefit him politically and harm Democratic political rival Joe Biden, and $391 million in security aid to Ukraine that Democrats accuse Trump of using as leverage on a vulnerable U.S. ally.

"The bribe is to grant or withhold military assistance in return for a public statement of a fake investigation into the elections," House of Representatives Speaker Nancy Pelosi said on Nov. 14. "That's bribery." Trump has dismissed the impeachment inquiry as a partisan witch hunt.

There is an obvious appeal to framing Trump's conduct as bribery, legal experts say: not only is it an easy concept to grasp, but it is one of the two impeachable offenses specifically mentioned in the U.S. Constitution. However, what exactly constitutes "bribery" in the impeachment context is not clear cut. Wednesday's debate in the House Judiciary Committee centered around two different approaches: The broad Constitutional view that the term encompasses efforts to trade official actions for private benefits, and the narrower modern-day definition used by federal prosecutors in criminal cases.

Pamela Karlan, one of three law professors called to the hearing by Democrats, said that she believed that the writers of the Constitution would have thought Trump's actions rose to the level of bribery. Karlan, a professor at Stanford Law School, said they understood bribery to encompass "when you took private benefits, or asked for private benefits, in return for an official act."

In defining bribery for purposes of impeachment, Congress does not need to adhere to how that crime is defined under federal law, Karlan said. "When they say explicitly in the Constitution that the president can be impeached and removed from office for bribery, they weren't referring to a statute," said Karlan.

But Jonathan Turley, a scholar chosen to testify by the Republicans, argued that Democrats should stick to a definition of bribery in the U.S. criminal code, which the U.S. Supreme Court said in a 2016 decision should be defined narrowly. The Supreme Court has made clear that "it is a dangerous thing to take a crime like bribery and apply a boundless interpretation," Turley said, adding "what I would caution the committee is that these crimes have meaning."

Turley, a professor at George Washington University, also testified that in other modern impeachments of U.S. presidents, there was little debate that the alleged wrongdoing violated U.S. criminal laws.

(This story has not been edited by Devdiscourse staff and is auto-generated from a syndicated feed.)


TRENDING

OPINION/BLOG/INTERVIEW

Hyderabad Encounter: Time to review modern judiciary and restore people’s confidence

Its probably for the first time in the history of independent India, the parliamentarians, chief ministers and ministers in the Union and State governments are openly supporting an encounter. This indicates the people from top to bottom hav...

What happens to your outstanding loans if the bank falls?

... ...

Time for a change! Innovations to stop the growing plastic pollution

As the planet is drowning in plastic pollution, many new innovative approaches and solutions have emerged to effectively deal with the menace....

How to avoid fake universities and fishing bait like Farmington

As education sharks are roaming around to prey, we present a guide on how to mitigate hunters and reach to a genuine universityinstitute. In this era of commercialization of education, the fake universities and economic frauds in educationa...

Videos

Latest News

Karnataka leaders visit temples for victory in bypolls

Ahead of the counting of votes for the byelections at 15 assembly segments, leaders in Karnataka visited temples and Maths on Sunday seeking divine intervention. Chief Minister B S Yediyurappa went to Dharmasthala and sought the blessings ...

Trump warns N.Korea has 'everything' to lose through hostile acts

Washington, Dec 8 AFP President Donald Trump warned Sunday that North Korea had everything to lose through hostility towards the United States, after Pyongyang said it had carried out a major new weapons test. Kim Jong Un is too smart and h...

Indian Ocean island Mayotte on cyclone alert

Mamoudzou, Dec 8 AFP The small French Indian Ocean island of Mayotte announced a red alert as Cyclone Belna closed in on Sunday, threatening the French department of quarter of a million people. The storm was expected to make landfall in Ma...

Sonia Chahal, Bhagyabati Kachari lead Railways to 6 gold medals

World Championships silver medallist Sonia Chahal 57kg and India Open Gold medallist Bhagyabati Kachari 81kg won the top prizes as Railways continued their dominance by clinching six gold medals at the Womens National Boxing Championships h...

Give Feedback