Debating the Legacy of Vande Mataram: A Forgotten History of Exclusion and Division

DMK MP A Raja claimed that Vande Mataram was historically used to sideline Muslims, framing it as a Hindu-only anthem. He questioned the divisions stemming from the song and pointed out past criticisms. TMC MP Kakoli Dastidar highlighted how the song fueled the Independence struggle and criticized current perceptions.

DMK MP A Raja, in a Lok Sabha discussion, asserted that Vande Mataram historically marginalized Muslims, being projected as a Hindu-centric anthem. He posed critical questions about the divisive nature of the anthem and its historical context, suggesting that the division it created was not initiated by Muslims.

Raja cited historical documentation and debates, pointing out that early 20th-century criticisms argued the anthem was against both the British and Muslims. He also referenced historian R C Majumdar in claiming patriotism intertwined with religious motives. The Parliament of the era even questioned the communal tensions associated with the anthem.

Trinamool Congress MP Kakoli Ghish Dastidar supported the anthem's role in the Independence struggle, criticizing contemporary political narratives. She argued against minimizing the contributions of figures like Bankim Chandra Chattopadhyay, emphasizing the deep-seated patriotism of Bengalis.

(With inputs from agencies.)